Categories
Gaming

Enderal: Thoughts on the Cycle — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/enderal, in the thread “[SPOILERS] Thoughts after finishing the game (it was fantastic)”, copied here as written.

It seems that the cycle was invented because at a certain point in humanity’s development they reach a stage of prosperity which is the pinnacle and beyond which no further progress can be made. So, when humanity nears that point, their collective peak consciousness is turned into a High One instead of letting them fester and rot.

The Veiled Woman is slowly creating a race of super-beings that individually represent the peak of their respective civilizations by manipulating the recurring characters in each cycle.

The Black Libra seems to be a group that somehow persists throughout the cycles and wants to find a way to get this to stop (as it is mass extermination). This includes hurting down anyone that may give birth to a Prophet.

The Rhalata, Kor cult, and others who “transcend” seem to be pre-emptively joining this human collective mind before the cycle. They aren’t doing anything different than what the Beacon accomplishes, just on a much smaller scale.

The Aged Man seems to be a prophet from many cycles ago who has the same objectives as the Black Libra even if he doesn’t collaborate with them neccesarily.

Essentially the entire game is the prophet thinking he is advancing goals similar to the Libra’s while also believing the Libra to be evil all the while inadvertently advancing the goals of the Veiled Woman & the High Ones.

The questions of: is it a bad thing for humanity to be coalesced into this single super intelligence, is it morally wrong for the Libra to kill innocents in their attempts to stop it, is the Veiled Woman even a moral agent, how much agency do the High Ones have if they were forced to become High Ones, should transcendence be voluntary like in the case of the Rhalata, etc. are not really explored by the time you figure any of this out – and maybe it’s better we draw our own opinions.

Posted January 25, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Film & Television

Revisiting The Fellowship of the Ring

These are my Letterboxd reviews, copied as written. They may contain spoilers.

My rating: 5 out of 5

Listening to Peter Jackson ramble on about shooting the mines of Moria scenes in a dragon button up was a treat.

There’s a lot more deus ex machina to save the Fellowship than I remember.

Orcs are the most useless minions ever. Even Merry & Pippin are killing them without serious injury. The Fellowship is consistently facing 10 to 1 odds and coming out unscathed.

Perhaps it would have been more impactful if Gandalf stayed dead but knowing Tolkein it is probably a Jesus motif.

Frodo being nearly stabbed to death twice wasna bit overused, with the deus ex mythril saving him the second time.

Why are only short characters used for comic relief (dwarves & Hobbits) but humans are always regal or power hungry?

While most of the effects hold up in 2026, some of the green screen & effects definitely do not stand the test of time.

Overall, it still is & always will be a masterpiece. It spawned an entire genre and may still be the best high fantasy ever written, with the movie being one of the greatest cinematic experiences in history. Even when contrasted with Game of Thrones that had more source material, a much higher budget, the benefit of being at a much later stage of development in the genre – Lord of the Rings stands head and shoulders above it. The political maneuvering of GoT or the darker themes of The Witcher may represent an achievement, but the charm, ethics, & world of Middle Earth still reigns supreme.

(Although Enderal remains my favorite high fantasy story)

Watched January 23, 2026. My review on Letterboxd.

More of my film diary is on Letterboxd, and more of what I watch, read and eat is on my portfolio: alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

“Bring One Surah Like It”: The Qur’an’s Challenge — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “Bring one surah like it, or… ten like it!”, copied here as written.

This requires buying into the paradigm of naturalistic phenomenon being objectively true and provable but non-naturalistic phenomenon being either nonexistant or unprovable. That is a very clear bias.

If I were to ask you, on what basis besides blind faith or modern academic convention, should we accept that naturalistic phenomenon are true or real – what would the academic of Quranic studies say?

If we’re taking a truly hard materialistic stance, then you can’t rely on the epistemological/ontological systems of secular philosophers like Hegel.

So how does the secular academic of Quranic studies prove that naturalism is a justifiable approach to attaining “unbiased” knowledge?

If you had said, “secular academia makes numerous assumptions and does not bother itself with justifying them, one of them being that supernatural beings do not exist” that would have been tenable.

But the claim of “unbiased” is provably false.

Posted January 17, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Were Bukhari and Muslim Driven by Politics? — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/MuslimAcademics, in the thread “Muslim and bukhari, their hadith were not free from political motive & alliances that do not aling with quran message. Dr KAEF”, copied here as written.

Imagine trying to reduce the entire Sunnah corpus to the political motivations of the narrators and even claiming riwayat about fada’il al-a’mal are wholesale so Ummayyad “authoritarians” can justify their soldiers massacring people.

This is so silly and intellectually dishonest it almost doesn’t warrant a response but alarmingly a lot of people are agreeing with this.

How does he explain many of these same narrations making it into Shi’a hadith collections, that had decidedly anti-Ummayyad political leanings?

Why is it not possible these hadith were fabricated for business reasons and not political ones, since we are speculating? Actually the hadith about Hajj is because the Arabs wanted people to travel to Makkah & Madinah for commerce. And the hadith about forgiveness of sins in Ramadan is about the Arab grocers/butchers wanting people to purchase more food for extravagant iftars. And the hadith about praying 5 times a day washing the sins away is because the prayer mat sellers wanted people praying more.

It’s one thing to take a more critical lens of hadith or matn criticism. It is another thing to blindly speculate on entirely opaque political or financial or other motivations. This is why the muhadithun attempted to develop a neutral historiographical method for determining the reliability of the hadith.

Without the sanad anyone can just say anything they want, and that’s exactly what we see here.

Posted January 14, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Society & Culture

Is Anything Real That Cannot Be Measured? — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/PhilosophyMemes, in the thread “What reason is there to consider or discuss anything that cant be measured?”, copied here as written.

  1. This is not true
  2. This is not an accurate way to phrase it
  3. Being an epistemological materialist or an empiricist is not the only alternative to solipsism. It’s the least philosophically robust position. There are 2000 years of thinkers dealing with these issues and for most of that time materialism was not taken seriously. Nowadays, people that don’t understand philosophy take materialism for granted because the West was captured by Hegelian dialectic (allowing both main wings of Western philosophy, analytic & Continental, to stop doing epistemology, ontology, and metaphysics).

The problem is this: since people assume Hegel & his derivatives solved philosophy, they also assume their naieve materialism is superior to everything else. That’s despite the fact that Post-Hegelian thought is not naieve materialism.

Simply put, the materialism or pop empiricism worldview is unjustifiable and is no better than solipsism. That doesn’t mean other worldviews are unjustifiable and no better than solipsism. In fact, I would argue most historical approaches have some value over outright solipsism. Just not materialism.

Anyone that holds firmly to materialism should also accept nihilistic moral subjectivity and the possibility of solipsism, in which case their worldview cannot lay any claim to truth, morality, or superiority over any other worldview. The most comic book villain evil plot has the same ethical weight as a masterialistic approach – since ethics are not real and perhaps neither is reality.

Posted January 8, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Who Counts as a Muslim, and Is Jumuʿah Obligatory? — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as comments on r/MuslimAcademics, in the thread “Is attending the Friday prayer (Jumu'ah) in mosques obligatory in today's times? Here's what I found in Javed Ahmed Ghamidi's forum. It's a very interesting read”, copied here as written.

Comment 1

To summarize the views of modernists, including some views of Javed Ghamidi:

Jummu’ah – not required

Hadith/Sunnah – not reliable

Salah – men in front of women is misogynistic. We need female imams! It’s Arabo-centric to require salah in Arabic as well.

Hajj – not required because Saudi is a corrupt profiteering backwards country

Hijab – not required

Beard – not required

Islamic exclusivism – not required. Allah can forgive good people of all faiths. Jews & Christians are “believers” as well

Zakah – not required. You pay government taxes, that’s not enough.

Belief in the Unseen – these are metaphors for scientific concepts.

Hellfire – not eternal

My question is this: why call oneself a Muslim at all at this point? Why bind oneself to a label which denotes everything one opposes? This has gone beyond an identity crisis.

Posted December 31, 2025. Read it on Reddit.

Comment 2

If Islam doesn’t have a clear definition and none of us can determine who is or is not a Muslim then why do you care about mending rifts between Muslims? There’s nothing we can clearly distinguish so there’s nothing to dispute over.

Unless what you’re concerned about is the feelings of people who claim to adhere about Islam. Which is not something that figures as a primary consideration for me.

I value Islam as a distinct way of life and an articulable belief system that is clearly defined so I will continue to be aware of its boundaries so that the tradition I inherited can be preserved for the future. Hashalillahi to accuse Him of being unable to clarify the Way He wants us to follow.

Posted January 3, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Qurayshi Polytheism Was Syncretic, Not Organized — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/Muslim, copied here as written.

Qurayshi polytheism is a syncretic religion, not an organized one. Therefore, there were henotheists, polytheists, and even proto-atheist mushriks. Judaism revolves around a text which Jews return to and by which their identity is distinguished. The same is true for Christianity. A Christian that denies Jesus is definitionally not a Christian.

However, a mushrik that denies Lat can still be a mushrik. A mushrik that believes only Allah is the true God can still be a mushrik. A mushrik that thinks all of the gods are made up can still be a mushrik. That’s because Qurayshi mushrikun were syncretic, a mix of various religious traditions and personal opinion. There is no Qurayshi mushrik dogma.

In fact, the mushrikun were prepared to give rasulAllah power and “accept” Islam so long as they were allowed to host the idols for Hajj, as they feared removing them totally would harm trade. Yet rasulAllah rejected this, because being Muslim 359 days a year but accepting shirk for one STILL rendered them mushrikun and not Muslimun.

Some mushrikun believed Islam is true. Some believed all of the gods were just stories of the ancients. Some worshipped Lat & Uzza.

Posted January 1, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Society & Culture

Aptitude, Orientation and Belief — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as comments on r/PhilosophyMemes, in the thread “Metaphysically necessary possible modal worlds”, copied here as written.

Comment 1

Started off as a chem major through a program that allowed me to begin my undergrad in junior year of high school. Now hold a master’s in IT & work in software.

That being said, most STEM people see abstract reasoning & philosophy as an inferior kind of knowledge that requires lesser intelligence. This is a common problem with everyone that has specific aptitudes.

People who have high degrees of physical intelligence/capability, socio-emotional intelligence, see STEM people as weak nerds. They can win at life and enjoy it much more than them without staring at a book.

People with high degrees of ethical & abstract intelligence see STEM as being subordinate to armchair philosophizing.

There is a fundamental human problem with arrogance & delegitimizing areas of expertise that one is not naturally adept at.

STEM people are typically at a disadvantage in philosophical discussions in the same way philosophers are at a disadvantage in STEM. Attempts to bridge the divide, like the almost mathematical analytical approach, have not proven successful.

Posted December 30, 2025. Read it on Reddit.

Comment 2

Aptitude is the raw talent. Most people are biased towards their aptitude. But there are also orientations.

I can think painting and literature are the most sophisticated forms of human expression while myself having zero talent in either.

However, typically, people are biased towards the areas they are naturally apt in. This doesn’t have to be the case.

I can admire socialites & people with insight into human behavior or I can assume they’re superficial and interested in petty affairs. People that are naturally good with analyzing people will TEND to think this is a superior form of intelligence to one they are not born talented in, let’s say engineering, but do not NECCESARILY have to.

Hence engineering uber alles types or science uber alles types.

Myself, STEM is not my natural strong suit. It’s where I’m most formally educated, but ethical/abstract reasoning is much naturally stronger. I was always weakest in human intelligence (social, emotional, spatial, self preservation, etc.). Over time I came to appreciate it’s a category of intelligence I lack and need to develop.

Posted December 31, 2025. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Society & Culture

Can You Prove Consciousness Is Real? — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as comments on r/PhilosophyMemes, in the thread “The hard problem of actually reading a book”, copied here as written.

Comment 1

How can you be certain perceptual patterns are repeating and they aren’t the product of an evil demon or Boltzmann scenario where the repetitions are hallucinated? Furthermore what makes the repetitions impart true knowledge and what guarantees their continuation into the future? Couldn’t any or all of these patterns run their course and cease to provide the same experience?

Ultimately reliability is predicated on perception, I have to cede that, but if we ground it in a perceptual core instead of the noumenon at least theoretically we have no way to evaluate the reliability of that perception outside of itself (even if this third person is an abstraction for our purposes here)

Posted December 25, 2025. Read it on Reddit.

Comment 2

In philosophy, a noumenon (/ˈnuːmənɒn/, /ˈnaʊ-/; from Ancient Greek: νοούμενoν; pl.: noumena) is knowledge[1] posited as an object that exists independently of human sense.[2] The term noumenon is generally used in contrast with, or in relation to, the term phenomenon, which refers to any object of the senses. Immanuel Kant first developed the notion of the noumenon as part of his transcendental idealism, suggesting that while we know the noumenal world to exist because human sensibility is merely receptive, it is not itself sensible and must therefore remain otherwise unknowable to us.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noumenon

Your experience of you touching on a screen is not itself evidence. It is an experience. You must then prove to yourself that it is actually happening and then find a way to prove to me that it is happening and that all of the experiences every individual is happening are all also reliable. Just because it’s intuitive or seems to make sense to you doesn’t make it true.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evil_demon

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boltzmann_brain

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_skepticism

Posted December 26, 2025. Read it on Reddit.

Comment 3

Walking outside and being able to touch grass does not prove that your consciousness is real or that mine is real, just that something has some experience.

I believe you’re a real person with an internal world, but I don’t believe materialism can ever prove that.

You’re getting frustrated. My question is very simple. How can you, as a materialist, prove that anything outside of the experiences you witness exist? How can you prove, using only material and naturalistic explanations, that:

  1. Your senses are reliable
  2. You are truly experiencing an external world
  3. Other people have inner worlds similar to yours
  4. Their perception is similar to yours
  5. You are interacting with these people

If you cannot do that, your philosophy (materialism) is less valid than solipsism – which we both agree is not thr case.

Posted December 29, 2025. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Film & Television

What People Are Totally Missing about Pluribus

Pluribus is a mass ethical thought experiment. I haven't seen anyone discuss this but it's really the core message. The show is designed to ask the American (and international) public if we want to continue where we are going by showing us the ultimate outcome.

What do I mean?

There are three major kinds of ethics: deontological (a Higher Power determines what's right or wrong), virtue (what's right is what helps me become a better person), and consequentialist (the outcome determines what is right and wrong).

One of the main ethical dilemmas this show faces is about utilitarianism. Utilitarianism is a kind of consequentialism.

Utilitarianism is about maximizing happiness (utility) and minimizing suffering for the greatest number of people.

So what is good & ethical to a utilitarian is what brings happiness & pleasure. Causing pain & sadness are unethical or even evil.

Modern Western societies are utilitarian. Most secular people are utilitarian. Capitalism, democracy, republics, all of these are fundamentally utilitarian systems.

What happens when you take utilitarianism to its logical conclusion? What if we didn't need science or technology to help us arrive at a maximal utilitarian state?

Enter the Hive.

The Hive is essentially a thought experiment on perfect utilitarianism. Without requiring people to volunteer, or a totalitarian state, or war; suddenly everyone has maximized utility essentially overnight.

The concept of the ends justifying the means is a dilemma for utilitarians, and one we have seen played out throughout the 20th century with Nazism & the mass killings under Communist regimes. We see it now with technofeudalism, AI, and the tech-bro utopia.

The hive believes the joining is ethical because it has brought happiness and pleasure to everyone on earth with the exception of Carol. They don't remove themselves from Carol until she causes them to suffer.

Diabaté is a utilitarian. He is seeking the shortest path to maximize his happiness. So is Laxmi. So are a lot of people who are primarily concerned with themselves and their well being. The hive has optimized happiness and well being.

So, these other survivors have no problem with the Hive or each other. They are operating on the same wavelength. They all want to be happy and maximize happines for everyone else. The Hive has accomplished that and brought peace on earth.

We see this taken to ridiculous extremes when the Hive brings Carol a grenade because she wants it and is willing to give her a nuclear bomb.

Carol and Manousos are not operating in a utilitarian paradigm. Perhaps Carol was before the joining, however she was beginning to struggle with achieving happiness by the easiest means neccesary and began seeking higher meaning/purpose (with her poorly written novel). She was developing an aesthetic component to her ethics.

She gave in in episode 7 to the pleasure principle and it left her feeling so hollow, alone, and empty that she was willing to essentially commit suicide. She can't find true human connection so she is seeking an emulation of it in Zosia.

While we don't know about Manousos' personal beliefs, much has been made of the Catholic environment he is from (and most likely raised in). We see Manousos holding very firmly to deontological ethical values about property, ownership, identity, authenticity and virtues like self-reliance. To Manousos, the ends do not justify the means. Being a good person is not about accomplishing your goal of maximizing happiness, it's about values that trasncend and therefore define humanity.

Hence his willingness to die before accepting help from the Hive, who he sees as unethically colonizing humanity & stealing its property collectively.

As we rapidly approach the terminal state of utilitarianism in the real world, Pluribus is asking us if we really want to live in such a world or whether there are other values that matter to us.

Is humanity more important than maximizing happiness? Is it worth having peace on earth even if we lose our individuality? Is scientific or technological autocracy justified if it ends suffering? Can advanced science or technology really solve our problems?

Analysis by Ali Shukri Amin


Originally posted by Ali Shukri Amin on Reddit. Read or join the discussion here: https://www.reddit.com/r/pluribustv/comments/1pngzn0/what_people_are_totally_missing_about_pluribus/