Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Rhyme, Recitation and the Written Text of the Qur’an — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “six Quranic rhymes that were lost due to adherence to the written text”, copied here as written.

I do agree there are alterations made to words for poetic reasons but these are inconsistently applied by both the scribes & the readers. A great example is the hā al-sakt in the Qira’ah of Ya’qub.

Continuous reading is not rare.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=k2FAdK-zKEY&pp=ygUi2LPZiNix2Kkg2KfZhNin2YbYtNmC2KfZgiDZiNi12YTYpw%3D%3D

These Verses are especially read with Wasl in Tarawih during Ramadan.

I don’t understand what method you’re using to determine these “hidden” rhymes other than that a few stand out to you but people have been reading the rhymes you mentioned in Qira’ah Wasl/Hadr for as long as we have documentation of that.

Posted August 31, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Why the Qur’an Criticizes Calling Scholars Lords — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “The Talmud has many figures called "my son" by God so why does the Quran single Eliezer Ben Hycarnus?”, copied here as written.

If we take the hadith of ‘Adi bin Hatim to have historical value, then the Qur’anic criticism of taking their monks & rabbis (ahbarahum wa ruhbanahum) as lords other than Allah was tied to legislative Lordship (Hakimiyyah), not direct deification. In Rabbinic tradition the Haver (Hibr in Arabic) has legislative authority, as a Talmudic “son of god.”

Therefore, the jurisprudential prominence of Eliezer & his capacity to legislate independently of Allah as a “son of god” constitutes a kind of legal deification. This is contrasted with the Christian theological deification.

It seems that the Quran is in discourse with statements of Eliezer that we can find in the Mishnah, just as it seems it is in discourse with Jacob of Serugh (or at least the traditions surrounding both figures).

Posted August 12, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Gaming

Disco Elysium: Dros and the Dread of Building a Better World

A reading of Disco Elysium, adapted from a discussion of its ending. Spoilers follow.

Dros is what happens when someone believes they are approaching something perfect only to lose it. Which is really what the entire game is about, moving past utopianism to the dread of slowly building a better world. Harry's utopia was Dora (symbolized by the accusedly perfect Innocence Dolores Dei).

Instead of Dros accepting that the communist revolution of Revachol failed but that very left wing forces still needed support, he calcified. As did Harry in losing Dora, as did the monarchists, fascists, moralists, etc.

The main characters in Disco Elysium are not actively taking practical measures to improve their world, they are either stagnant or regressing.

Dros is a perfect final boss because he is the culmination of believing that "The historic opportunity for a revolution has passed. It will not come back anymore. However hard I try, whatever I do."

Nothing Harry does will rewind the clock and bring Dora back to him. Nothing Dros does will bring back the revolution.

This is contrasted with the phasmid, a very Sufi or taoist figure who is "weightless." When it loses a limb, it tears it off and regrows it.

"You are a violent and irrepressible miracle. The vaccum of cosmos and the stars burning in it are afraid of you. Given enough time you would wipe us all out and replace us with nothing – just by accident."

The phasmid then tells you to turn away from the ruin (the relationship with Dora) and do it for the working class.

I am astounded at the amount of pain that must have informed the ending of Disco Elysium, between the dream of Dolores Dei and Iosef Dros the Deserter. It's the pain of profound earthshattering heartbreak and decimated political ambition and lost hope. But the conversation with the phasmid is so beautiful and profound, demonstrating that it is the way of nature to suffer such grievances yet evolve and thrive.


This began as a comment I wrote on Reddit. Read it in context here: https://www.reddit.com/r/DiscoElysium/comments/1vknc7u/yeah_id_say_that_pretty_accurate/p34jlcq/

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Do Any Sunnis Reject the Uprightness of the Companions? — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “Is there any Sunni sect that rejects Adalat al-Sahabah (Arabic: عدالة الصحابة)”, copied here as written.

Orthodox Sunnism acknowledges that some of the sahabah were hypocrites, such as Abdullah ibn Ubayy, but asserts that the sahabah as a class are saved and should not be criticized. This doesn’t mean that some Sunni scholars were not farther on the spectrum of Tashayyu’ or preferring Ali and critiquing Mu’awiyyah – such as al-Nasa’i. However, you’re not going to find a Sunni scholar calling Mu’awiyyah or his partisans a hypocrite as the boundaries of Sunnism are partially defined by holding the opposing doctrine.

By the time Sunnism exists historically, it is defined by upholding the uprightness of the sahabah.

Posted August 2, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.