Categories
Gaming

Disco Elysium: Favorite and Least Favorite Moments — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/DiscoElysium, in the thread “Just finished the game for the first time. Absolute cinema. What was your favorite moment and your least enjoyed one?”, copied here as written.

Favorite has to be the entire third act from the tribunal, Iosef the deserter (his dialogue & reasoning), & the phasmid.

Least favorite is also Iosef just because there was no way to kind of piece that together earlier on. The game gets off to a very slow start but is more than worth sticking to.

Read the thread on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Gaming

Disco Elysium: Dros and the Dread of Building a Better World

A reading of Disco Elysium, adapted from a discussion of its ending. Spoilers follow.

Dros is what happens when someone believes they are approaching something perfect only to lose it. Which is really what the entire game is about, moving past utopianism to the dread of slowly building a better world. Harry's utopia was Dora (symbolized by the accusedly perfect Innocence Dolores Dei).

Instead of Dros accepting that the communist revolution of Revachol failed but that very left wing forces still needed support, he calcified. As did Harry in losing Dora, as did the monarchists, fascists, moralists, etc.

The main characters in Disco Elysium are not actively taking practical measures to improve their world, they are either stagnant or regressing.

Dros is a perfect final boss because he is the culmination of believing that "The historic opportunity for a revolution has passed. It will not come back anymore. However hard I try, whatever I do."

Nothing Harry does will rewind the clock and bring Dora back to him. Nothing Dros does will bring back the revolution.

This is contrasted with the phasmid, a very Sufi or taoist figure who is "weightless." When it loses a limb, it tears it off and regrows it.

"You are a violent and irrepressible miracle. The vaccum of cosmos and the stars burning in it are afraid of you. Given enough time you would wipe us all out and replace us with nothing – just by accident."

The phasmid then tells you to turn away from the ruin (the relationship with Dora) and do it for the working class.

I am astounded at the amount of pain that must have informed the ending of Disco Elysium, between the dream of Dolores Dei and Iosef Dros the Deserter. It's the pain of profound earthshattering heartbreak and decimated political ambition and lost hope. But the conversation with the phasmid is so beautiful and profound, demonstrating that it is the way of nature to suffer such grievances yet evolve and thrive.


This began as a comment I wrote on Reddit. Read it in context here: https://www.reddit.com/r/DiscoElysium/comments/1vknc7u/yeah_id_say_that_pretty_accurate/p34jlcq/

Categories
Gaming

Enderal: Thoughts on the Cycle — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/enderal, in the thread “[SPOILERS] Thoughts after finishing the game (it was fantastic)”, copied here as written.

It seems that the cycle was invented because at a certain point in humanity’s development they reach a stage of prosperity which is the pinnacle and beyond which no further progress can be made. So, when humanity nears that point, their collective peak consciousness is turned into a High One instead of letting them fester and rot.

The Veiled Woman is slowly creating a race of super-beings that individually represent the peak of their respective civilizations by manipulating the recurring characters in each cycle.

The Black Libra seems to be a group that somehow persists throughout the cycles and wants to find a way to get this to stop (as it is mass extermination). This includes hurting down anyone that may give birth to a Prophet.

The Rhalata, Kor cult, and others who “transcend” seem to be pre-emptively joining this human collective mind before the cycle. They aren’t doing anything different than what the Beacon accomplishes, just on a much smaller scale.

The Aged Man seems to be a prophet from many cycles ago who has the same objectives as the Black Libra even if he doesn’t collaborate with them neccesarily.

Essentially the entire game is the prophet thinking he is advancing goals similar to the Libra’s while also believing the Libra to be evil all the while inadvertently advancing the goals of the Veiled Woman & the High Ones.

The questions of: is it a bad thing for humanity to be coalesced into this single super intelligence, is it morally wrong for the Libra to kill innocents in their attempts to stop it, is the Veiled Woman even a moral agent, how much agency do the High Ones have if they were forced to become High Ones, should transcendence be voluntary like in the case of the Rhalata, etc. are not really explored by the time you figure any of this out – and maybe it’s better we draw our own opinions.

Posted January 25, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Gaming

Alfrid, Gajus, and the Aged Man: An Enderal Theory

Enderal: The Shards of Order rewards the kind of attention most games never earn. It hides its most important claims in reused assets, misplaced letters, and characters who are standing exactly where they should not be. One small detail has stayed with me, and I think it points at something larger about how the game tells its story.

The detail: a shared face

The character model used for Yero’s friend in Riverville is the same model the game uses for Gajus. On its own that is the sort of asset reuse every large RPG relies on. But Enderal has a habit of making its reuse mean something, and once you notice this particular overlap it is hard to un-see.

The theory: Alfrid is the Aged Man

Here is the reading I keep coming back to. What if Alfrid is the Aged Man? Suppose he believed that Yero would become the Prophet, and so he infiltrated Riverville, befriended him, and positioned himself close to the person he expected prophecy to fall upon. That single assumption reorganizes a number of loose threads:

  • It explains why a figure with the Aged Man’s bearing would trouble himself with the small life of a river town.
  • It explains the mysterious letter in the Aged Man’s manor — a letter written to Yero, addressed to the person Alfrid took to be the coming Prophet.
  • And it explains the sting in the tail: the letter is found not by its intended reader but by the actual Prophet — you. The message was laid for one person and intercepted by the one prophecy really chose.

Why it fits Enderal’s method

Enderal is a story about being read wrong — about prophecy, projection, and people deciding in advance who you are supposed to become. A mentor who bets on the wrong candidate for Prophet, and only discovers his error when the real one stumbles on his correspondence, is exactly the kind of quiet dramatic irony the game builds its whole world out of. The shared character model stops looking like a budget decision and starts looking like a clue.

I am not claiming this as settled canon; Enderal leaves enough deliberately unresolved that certainty would betray the game. But as a lens it earns its keep, and it changes how the manor scene lands on a second playthrough.


This post expands on a discussion I started on Reddit. Read or join the original thread here: https://www.reddit.com/r/enderal/comments/1nz1j79/alfrid_gajus/

Categories
Gaming

What Enderal Says About the Body and the Soul

Most writing about Enderal: The Shards of Order is plot commentary — excellent lore deep-dives like Paradigm of Low’s, but plot deep-dives all the same. What I have wanted to read, and never quite found, is a thematic account: something that ties the game’s recurring images — fleshlessness, the Rhalata’s ascension, the Cycle, the Butcher — into a single claim about the body and the soul. This is my attempt to sketch one.

The Cycle as a problem about matter

Enderal’s central engine is the Cycle: civilizations rise, reach a certain height, and are annihilated, over and over, by a force that works through minds and bodies alike. The horror of the Cycle is not only that it kills, but that it makes embodied existence look futile. If everything built in flesh is destined to be unmade, then the body starts to look less like a home and more like a sentence.

The Rhalata’s answer: escape the flesh

The Rhalata take that despair and build a program out of it. Their pursuit of “fleshlessness” is a bid to escape the Cycle by escaping the body — to ascend past matter into something the Cycle cannot touch. It is a coherent response to the game’s premise: if the body is where suffering and annihilation land, then salvation must lie in shedding it. The Rhalata are not simply villains; they are the logical conclusion of taking the Cycle’s verdict on the body at face value.

The counter-image: the Butcher and the cost of denial

Against that, the game keeps showing us what the denial of the body actually produces. The violence associated with figures like the Butcher, and the broader machinery of the Cycle, reads as what happens when the physical self is treated purely as an instrument — something to be used, discarded, or transcended rather than inhabited. The pursuit of fleshlessness does not abolish suffering; it relocates it onto other bodies.

What Enderal is saying

Read this way, Enderal’s answer to its own despair is not ascension. The game treats the wish to transcend the body as the very impulse that keeps the Cycle turning — a refusal of finitude that always, eventually, demands a sacrifice. Its quieter suggestion is the harder one: that meaning is only available inside embodied, mortal life, precisely because that life ends. The soul, in Enderal, is not what escapes the flesh. It is what is at stake in how we live while we are in it.

This is a reading, not a decoding. Enderal leaves room for others, which is part of why it stays worth arguing about.


This post expands on a discussion I started on Reddit. Read or join the original thread here: https://www.reddit.com/r/enderal/comments/1nvjc99/comprehensive_thematic_analysis/