Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Does the Historical-Critical Method Make Philosophical Blunders? — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “Does the HCM make philosophical blunders?”, copied here as written.

Every intellectual system makes assumptions the question is just whether those assumptions are reasonable or not. The HCM is inundated with assumptions at the metaphysical, ontological, epistemological, and methodological levels. Unfortunately, I have yet to see a single proponent of HCM who understands this. Even great scholars at the methodological level do not discuss this.

I wpuld argue HCM is woefully maladjusted to what we know about behavorial economics, the heuristics & biases tradition, and statistics at the methodological level. As for metaphysical, ontological, & epistemological that problem runs deeper than HCM & applies more broadly to modern Western humanities/social sciences.

Posted April 19, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Yasir Qadhi’s Divine Permission Model and the Seven Ahruf — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/MuslimAcademics, in the thread “Sh. Yasir Qadhi: The Divine Permission Model”, copied here as written.

While there is no doubt paraphrasing & word interpolation occurred, I don’t think this explains the Seven Ahruf hadith. In fact, it directly contradicts it. The hadith says the Quran was Revealed upon Seven Ahruf, and this view of Qadhi’s is saying, “actually the Quran was Revealed on one Harf & then people were allowed to add any number of variants.”

It seems more likely that the dispensation of paraphrasing had nothing to do with the Ahruf & was moreso a product of some of the Arabs not having a conceptualization of verbatim transmission.

I personally think shaykh Uthman Khan’s view (who taught Qadhi the Qira’at) is a lot better. His opinion is that the Ahruf are literally Huruf (letters), referring to 7 letters that are not present across all of the dialects of Arabic. So that means the Quran was Revealed accomodating these 7 letters so all of the Arabs could pronounce it.

Posted February 28, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Ibn Taymiyya and the Revival of Early Hanbali Conclusions — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “Did Ibn Taymiyyah create a hyper conservative strand of Atharism, or rather continue it's legacy?”, copied here as written.

Ibn Taymiyyah revived the conclusions of the early Hanbalites which the Atharis/Hanbalis had gradually moved away from. Generally speaking, the first & second wave of Hanbalis leaned extremely literalist and sometimes borderline anthropomorphist.

Eventually the school was forced to justify some of the more incredulous views leading to qaḍī Abu Ya’la’s attempt to create an almost Hanbali kalām, ibn Jawzī attempting to argue Hanbalism is a kind of relegationist Asharism (tafwīd), ibn Aqīl adopting some Mutazili views, etc.

Eventually ibn Qudama was able to codify a kind of Atharism that was palatable without delving much into Kalām and with rejecting the more extreme interpretations of the earlier Hanbalites. He really toed the line between tafwid & “ithbat”.

Ibn Taymiyyah wanted to reconcile all of mainstream Hanbali history while boasting the facially problematic views of the early Atharis and justifying them as the legitimate views. So, his conclusions initially seem to agree with the hardline Hanbali theologians. After all, this is what he himself claims.

This is a superficial reading of ibn Taymiyyah.

Ibn Taymiyyah was a unique creative thinker & a philosopher who introduced views no one before him had ever articulated. In some cases he agreed with the Mu’tazilah, in others the early Hanbalis, in others the later Hanbalis, in others he had his own views entirely.

Ibn Taymiyyah’s system of Atharism begins by repudiation of formal logic as intially described by Aristotle, going so far as to critique the very idea of a syllogism. He then develops his own theory of linguistics (al-asmā al-mutakafi’ah) and tries to demonstrate that it was the default operant one since the time of Sibawayh until Asharites adopted Greek philosophy.

From there, he brings his own theory of linguistics & repudiation of the rules of formal logic to the Ṣifat controversy, atomism, causality, predestination, and almost every other issue you can think of.

Ibn Taymiyyah was a unique & revolutionary Islamic thinker who is still poorly understood today in large part because he adopted the trappings of hyper orthodoxy. He himself believed that he was just justifying a literalist and originalist approach to Islam. However, he never shied away from disagreeing with conclusions that contradicted his idiosyncratic and sophisticated system of thought. So while ibn Taymiyyah has been read as a strict Hanbali, I think it’s more fruitful to look at the vastness of his methodological thinking than the label he insists you apply to him.

What modern people think of as a Salafi is more akin to Mohammed bin Abd al-Wahhab who was greatly influenced by ibn Taymiyyah but certainly did not appreciate the finer nuances of his school. Even then, it’s moreso 2nd wave Wahhabism than MIAW proper.

Posted February 26, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Film & Television

Resurrection (2025): Cinema Against the Ephemeral

These are my Letterboxd reviews, copied as written. They may contain spoilers.

My rating: 5 out of 5

Seen at the National Museum of Asian Art, Freer Gallery:

The motion picture itself is a kind of rebellion against the ephemral nature of life. Everything that lives ultimately dies and is erased. A film is an attempt to capture a microcosm, to construct an ideal simulacrum of life and render it available for repeated future viewings.

This movie is a celebration of cinema’s rebellion against transcience & a meditation on the beauty of impermanent things.

I don’t typically enjoy anthologies. I would rather have one fully fleshed out idea than several half-baked ones. And each of the five stories here could have been their own movie.

What makes Resurrection unique is the clear central theme & persistent character of the delieriant. It is him dying & being reborn until the end of time, experiencing countless transient moments. Some of them are truly horrific, whereas others are full of indescribable joy.

Somehow Bi Gan has done the unthinkable. In a 2 1/2 hour runtime, he has crafted an amazing silent short, a supernatural crime noir, a meditative Buddhist ghost story, a charming adopted son crime drama, and a vampire romance. All within the context of a sci-fi dystopia.

Typically, these kinds of films can come off as incredibly disjointed. That was my problem with Coogler’s Sinners – too many good ideas packed into one story. Bi Gan could certainly have turned Resurrection into a series of films. Yet, there is a kind of emotional coherence & plot muddiness that makes this work.

Resurrection is also full of some of the best cinematography the medium has ever known. It is as if Bi Gan was able to distill some of the greatest shots in cinema history & give himself a canvas to weave them all together. Whether the shocking image of a Chinese detective in ’60s clothing cutting open a covert operative only to catch aflame from the mystical dimension underneath his skin to a haunted Buddhist temple in the early morning being speckled by snow to the image of an estranged daughter’s final burnt letter floating out of a box into the wind or a vampire crime overlord singing karaoke as his goons beat a man almost to death. Each of these pistáches is brought together in this kalodeiscopic tapestry of cinematic excellence.

In the end, Bi Gan pays his respects to the audience themselves. Casting us as beings of pure light in the cathedral of art, as each moviegoer fades into nothingness.

An absolutely singular ode to the always fading beauty of life & cinema.

Watched February 15, 2026. My review on Letterboxd.

More of my film diary is on Letterboxd, and more of what I watch, read and eat is on my portfolio: alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

What “Qīla” Means in a Tafsir — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/MuslimAcademics, in the thread “Ibn Ashur wrote in his tafsir on verse 24:31 that a group of mufassirs said women can expose face, hands, feet & hair. It will probably look like this when applied practically & I have some questions regarding this as this creates confusion in my mind”, copied here as written.

For point #3 you ask if it’s a mistake. Typically when a scholar mentions “qīla” without citing a source, they intend to indicate that it is a fringe opinion held by unreliable people not worth mentioning. Ibn Ashur’s tafsir is encyclopedic & he attempts to provide an exhaustive analysis of nearly every issue of tafsir. The fact that he mentions hair in one word tells you he thinks this is a settled issue and is giving only the most miniscule reference to this shādh view.

If we are truly free to select whatever views have been espoused in the past without respect for “tradition” in fiqh, why is it always the views that make us more aligned with modern secular lifestyle? There are many shadh views on a variety of topics.

For example, ibn Abbas held that mut’ah was not fully abrogated. Why can’t I engage in several mut’ah marriages with several Muslim sisters? Because we would find it morally reprehensible? Yet I can provide evidence for it.

Or the shādh view of Ahmad & ibn Hazm with respect to seeing a woman I intend to marry nude prior to marriage. Why can’t I combine that with the view a marriage contract is not required & mahr can be as little as we agree? Let’s add the Hanafi view that she needs no male wali. So long as two witnesses witness our agreement, I can give her a few coins, and this is essentially halal prostitution.

There is an exhaustive form of internal review, critique, & improvement in Islamic jurisprudence. It’s called the madhahib. If we discard them entirely and begin seeking out obscure views, then anyone can claim whatever they want.

It’s the equivalent of people rejecting medical advice from reputable universities because they researched on youtube.

Posted February 4, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Literacy Among the Arabs in the Prophet’s Time — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “About the lack of literacy of the Arabs in the time of the Prophet Muhammad”, copied here as written.

This adds interesting color to the above post. It seems that the way to reconcile them is:

A literate society is one that requires a writing system for functionality, which means enough people that participate in the economy or government need to be able to read.

How “literate” those people are varies from the base level of functionality needed to sign a document, inscribe their name, perform basic calculations – to being able to read works of complex literature.

Pre-Islamic Arabia seems to be a literate society with most literate people being basically functional and a few, mostly due to their need to engage with Jewish/Christian scriptures, being highly literate.

Is that how you understand it as well?

Posted February 2, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Society & Culture

First Principles, Reality and Descartes — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as comments on r/PhilosophyMemes, in the thread “No wait a damn minute…Descartes? Hello?”, copied here as written.

Comment 1

The whole point of the meme is that what you consider “reality” requires some first principle to justify it otherwise Cartesian doubt becomes solipsistic, evil demon, Pyyrhonian, and even deeper layers of doubt.

Your choices are:

1) God of the philosophers (the vast majority of philosophy before the young Hegelians)

2) Radical skepticism (I don’t know if anything is real)

3) Some kind of idealism that lends to focusing solely on phemomenal experience, like a modified Hegelian dialectic

4) Naieve materialism (doesn’t make any sense, is not actually a justifiable position. Hurr durr it’s real because I see it)

Posted January 28, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Comment 2

I misspoke. Skepticism is the one posing the problem. Philosophical theism & idealism are attempts at solving it. There are some “materialists” who are not naieve but I lump them in with idealists because it’s more methodological differences than foundational ones.

Naieve materialism is not semantically different than idealism, it’s substantively different.

Philosophical theism suggests that a God is the fundamental anchor upon which epistemology can be based, because if there is a benevolent transcendent guarantee that our cognition is not outright deceptive – then we can begin to evaluate other things. This is Plato’s form of the Good or Decartes benevolent God.

Kant & Hegel turn to ontology to try to construct an epistemology based in the phenomenon without recourse to the noumenon. While Hegel did believe in God, his work in this regard is definitely the pinnacle of a non-theistic approach to solving the major problems proposed by skeptics. I don’t think he succeeds.

Naieve materialists have benefitted from the fallout of Hegelian dialectic & the young Hegelians, assume hard philosophy (metaphysics, ontology, epistemology) is just “solved” because it’s so obvious that the material world is real dude.

We end up getting a scenario where the robust options are: theism, idealism, or radical skepticism.

Posted January 28, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Comment 3

My original comment,

The whole point of the meme is that what you consider “reality” requires some first principle to justify it otherwise Cartesian doubt becomes solipsistic, evil demon, Pyyrhonian, and even deeper layers of doubt.

Your choices are:

1) God of the philosophers (the vast majority of philosophy before the young Hegelians)

2) Radical skepticism (I don’t know if anything is real)

3) Some kind of idealism that lends to focusing solely on phemomenal experience, like a modified Hegelian dialectic

4) Naieve materialism (doesn’t make any sense, is not actually a justifiable position. Hurr durr it’s real because I see it)

Let’s focus on,

“3) Some kind of idealism that lends to focusing solely on phemomenal experience, like a modified Hegelian dialectic”

I just said Marx is a dialectical materialist & young Hegelian. How did I adjust my stance at all?

Posted January 29, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

What Is Islam? On Shahab Ahmed’s The Importance of Being Islamic — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as comments on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “What Is Islam? The Importance of Being Islamic by Shahab Ahmed”, copied here as written.

Comment 1

I think there is value in distinguishing between the intellectual scholarly tradition of Sunnism, i.e. Sunni Islam, and this much wider sociological, civilizational, anthropological approach (the Islamicate). Something can be Islamic (part of the Islamicate) without being in accordance to the prescriptions or descriptions of traditional scholarship (Islam).

I would hesitate to call the practice of Ottoman prostitutes wearing niqab to hide their faces an “Islamic” phenomenon because that risks attributing it to the prescriptions of Din, but it is certainly a phenomenon of the Islamicate in that it could only arise in a Muslim society that cares about certain Islamic values.

There definitely is a reductionist approach both to Sunni Islam & to Islamicate so thanks for sharing this excerpt.

Posted January 27, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Comment 2

If we believe that there is objectivity to doctrine & practice then we would distinguish between normativity & heterodoxy. Do we think that the earliest Muslims & their broad strokes understanding of the Quran has authority? Or is “Islam” a much more fluid concept.

I would argue that we never conflate Christianity with Christendom. We wouldn’t call capitalism “Christian” simply because it is difficult to imagine modern capitalism arising out of anything other than Calvanism & Protestantism (see Talal Assad). We would call capitalism a model that has Christian “features” in the same way that prominent atheist Richard Dawkins says he is “culturally Christian.”

Do the Diwan of Hafez represent Islam or are they a product of Islamicate? Can we say that when Hafez says he uses God’s hair as braids for his swing, this coheres with Islamic monotheism? Or would we say that Hafez is a poet with Islamic features?

Posted January 27, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Comment 3

I think it’s ahistorical to claim definitively that Muslims did not make these distinctions. If that were the case, there wouldn’t be so much scholarly literature lambasting poets, metaphyiscians, and mystics! Muslim traditional scholarship made a huge deal around determining “authentic” expressions of Islam – in other domains than theological & legal.

Even if we concede that most Muslims throughout most of history do not make this distinction.

There is a large body of literature analyzing the works of ibn Arabi, Rumi, Farabi, ibn Sina, Kindi, Abu Bakr al-Razi, and others to attempt to parse what is “Islamic” and what is not. While the poets, philosophers, and mystics themselves may not have cared – it was certainly a concern. In some places & times more than others for sure. But there was not a universal laissez faire attitude as you seem to be alluding to.

Some of the seminal works of Islam/Islamicate are borne out of a response to perceived un-Islamic influences. Look at Ghazali’s Tuhfat al-Falasifa or ibn Taymiyyah’s Critique of Greek Logic or Abu Hatim al-Razi’s refutation of Abu Bakr al-Razi.

There was a constant dialectic around authenticity. For sure, what is and is not “authentic” changed and there was/is a very wide degree of subjectivity. But it was definitely something Muslims concerned themselves with.

It could even be argued that whenever the line between Islam & Islamicate blurred too much, there was almost always a revivalist movement that attempted to parse the two. Whether Abu Hasan al-Ashari, al-Ghazali, ibn Taymiyyah, Uthman Dan Fodio, Shah WaliAllah al-Dihlawi, Mohammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab, Rashid Rida, etc.

The puritanical impulse of Sunnism (& to some degree Shi’ism) constantly, on a historical scale, gives birth to movements attempting to excise syncretic elements.

Posted January 27, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Comment 4

I don’t think scholarship’s past failures to acknowledge products of Islamicate which fall outside of traditional scholarly orthodoxy as being intellectually rigorous or valuable or worthy of study should cause us to totally eliminate useful demarcations & adopt a totally sociological or anthropological lense. There is definitely a constructed orthodoxy that has held dominant intellectual sway and there are definitely a lot of important currents that don’t fit into that fold which should also be analyzed. But if we don’t demarcate what is what and just go based off of frequency it will put any conclusions we come to out of step – since the Muslims in these syncretic or quasi-orthodox strains do still think in thisnway themselves!

Posted January 27, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Comment 5

Yes, if at some point Rumi or Hafez were incorporated widely into traditional madrasah studies. Not in a sense of supplementary material that requires a great deal of work to bring it into the fold of orthodoxy but as a staple part of the curriculum, it would cross over into being a product into something mainstream with a capital “I”.

The closest analogue is probably al-Busayri. While far less prolific than either Rumi or Hafez, his Burda has become a part of the institution of orthodoxy. This is despite extremely vehement debates about whether it crosses the line. But for whatever reason, the Burda is recited, studied, analyzed, and written about extensively in traditional scholarship across languages.

If you go to an Islamic seminary anywhere, except perhaps Farsi speaking Shi’i ones & some Hanafi or Hanafi-sympathetic neotraditonalists, and quote Rumi or Hafez to prove a point – you’ll raise an eyebrow. There’s certainly no Salafi madrasah or community that would accept it, you’d be hard pressed to find Maliki or Shafi’is that did. Even among Hanafis, Deobandis would be hit-or-miss.

Certainly in the past with Rumi & Hafez specifically, they were more widely acclaimed and valued, but still on the periphery of mainstream Sunni intellectual thought. It is extremely common to find Islamic texts in Arabic & Urdu quoting poetry, but rare to ever find them quoting Rumi or Hafez.

Perhaps they were even closer in the past to being enshrined or canonized so to speak. But the Sufi tariqas have fallen out of favor internationally, which would have been a primary way especially for Rumi.

That’s not to say that they didn’t have a huge outsized impact on the scholarly class & laymen, but they were consciously excluded by the scholarly class from “orthodoxy” for the most part. Which means lay people rarely hear their verses on the pulpit or in the mosque.

Ghazali was himself quite contentious after his life, with Hanbalites rejecting him outright & his books being burned in Andalus. But he was ultimately incorporated into the orthodoxy, serving as the basis for Avicennan Asharism, Shafi’i usul with al-Mustasfa, & reformulated Sunni tasawuf.

Posted January 27, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Comment 6

The problem this poses is that you lack a way to effectively communicate anything about Islam.

Simple question: is Islam monotheistic or pantheistic?

Well when we look at al-Hallaj, ibn Arabi, the Falasifa, and some of Hafez/Rumi we would conclude it’s pantheistic. These are interpretations based on the Quran.

But the vast majority of scholarship & Muslim masses would vehemently oppose this characterization.

Does Islam prescribe praying five times a day?

Again, some groups believe that this is abrogated when one reaches “Certainty” or that this is the exoteric of the text while the esoteric reality suggests not (Batiniyyah).

So we will need, at the very least, some rough guidelines as to what constitutes “Islam” versus what constitutes “Sunnism” or “Shi’ism” versus what is a cultural product of Muslims.

I don’t see how a totally postmodern approach helps us understand anything better.

Posted January 27, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Comment 7

I think there’s definitely a mainstream Islam that is consistent throughout scholarly readings & the largest denominations from the beginning until the current day. It is hard to imagine NOW Ghazali being excised from that since he has become a part of the edifice of Sunni orthodoxy specifically. Islam would need to change so drastically for that to occur.

I don’t know of any circumstance where religious Muslims rebelled or protested against their scholarship to the point where the views of the masses were markedly different than the scholarly class. Usually, traditional scholars are just very learned religious Muslims that know more about the same things they already agree about and are stricter against syncretic influences/more iconoclastic.

These scholars write books which are passed on and become reference points for later people trying to understand whaf Islam is.

Again, I’m not speaking from a place of objective correctness but rather dispassionate analysis to try to identify what is and is not Islam versus Islamicate.

Posted January 28, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Comment 8

I think you’re overestimating the prominance of tariqas/zawiyyahs in much of the world and definitely overestimating the penetration of Rumi/Hafez. Rumi & Hafez have had very little discernible impact in Arabic (I say this as a fan of Rumi). Even the great Farid al-Din al-Attar who wrote in Arabic & has perhaps the greatest epic poem of Islamicate civilization has very little impact.

I do concede their outsize influence among Persian & Turkic Hanafi Sufis & Shi’a. That being said, there have always been Hanafis who held serious reservations about them.

When we look at madrasah curriculums currently & historically, we don’t tend to see Rumi or Hafez as staple texts for spiritual instruction or even as supplemental texts. They’re moreso devotional works for aesthetic enjoyment & personal/communal enlightenment – which demonstrates that they were not considered to be scholarly or pieces of what constitutes orthodoxy.

I don’t think it’s useful to define Islam from the popular religious practices of masses.

In the Islamic Maghrib, Sufi tariqas had already decomposed by the time Mohammad Mawlud was writing about Tasawuff. Ahmad Zarruq also has a litany of criticisms for the decaying institution of organized Sufism. I don’t think it’s fair to attribute this to Salafism. There was a deep ossification of these institutions that made the ground ripe for Salafi repudiation.

The Salafi Egyptian repudiation of Egyptian Sufism has little in common with the Peninsular Salafism’s repudiation of Peninsular Sufism. Which has less in common with the Maghribi Salafi repudiation or the Malay Archipelago.

That being said Rumi was controversial even early on and Hafez even moreso. Rumi acknowledges & tries to pre-empt some of the criticisms that will be lodged against some of his verses but I don’t see that in my lay reading of Hafez.

Posted January 28, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Comment 9

The Mu’tazila are a great stress test because they’re really on the cusp between sects. I would argue initially there was much confusion as to whether they were “Islamic” or not because orthodoxy itself and therefore Islam as we conceive of it today was still being constructed. That being said, Islam =/= Sunnism. The Mutazilah held that there is One God, Muhammad is His Prophet, the Quran is God’s inerrant Word, & that we must imitate the Prophet. They believed in the 5 pillars and 6 articles of faith. So, the Mutazilah are Islamic – even if most Sunnis consider them to be heretical (I think there’s a softening happening now).

Islam should be something broad, relatively unchanging, and not extremely particular – but clearly definable. Whereas Islamicate can have much more variety and be less tangible. Islam produces Islamicate.

Ibn Taymiyyah is definitely Islamic as is Ghazali. Whether they represent Sunnism or the most accurate interpretation of Sunnism is irrelevant, because the major broad strokes are there.

But is Farabi “Islam” or are his works a product of Islamicate?

Shi’ism would be a part of Islam but obviously not a part of Sunnism.

I would say any group that has certain doctrines, practices, & spiritual components would automatically fall under the definition of “Islam.” There’s fluidity & development but we can pretty easily decipher the broad strokes.

The Qaramitah are an Islamicate group that no Muslim group would consider Islamic, for example.

Posted January 28, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Comment 10

From a discursive tradition standpoint:

  1. Masajid are mentioned in the Quran & Sunnah
  2. Beautification of masajid is discussed in the Quran & Sunnah
  3. Orthodox scholarship had debates & discussions about masjid architecture & symbolism/icons

What would not be accounted for were certain kinds of things happening in & around masajid. For example, some masajid have basketball courts to attract the youth. Is it a part of “Islam” or is it a part of “Islamicate”? Asad’s system can account for it as a secondary feature that doesn’t define Islam but is a part of Islamicate whereas to Ahmed the basketball court is actual lived Islam & what scholars have to say about it is not as important.

Posted January 28, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Society & Culture

Evolution and the Naturalistic Paradigm — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/PhilosophyMemes, in the thread “Evolution!!”, copied here as written.

Unfortunately while what you said seems much more consistent with a naturalistic paradigm, what is in the panel is constantly proposed by naturalists/materialists. If we accept evolution as an unguided process then it would be random, inefficient, often fail, and not be optimized for anything. It would just so happen that some subset of traits allowed enough of a survival advantage that they were passed on, but for whatever confluence of traits allowed for that, there would be a non-zero number of superfluous, counterintuitive, or “harmful” traits.

There would be no way to reliably test whether consciousness or reason was actually evolutionarily “advantageous” because we wouldn’t be able to run experiments across billions of years to control for it. That would also require us to define some desire end goal for evolution which it does not have, being a random process.

I’m not a naturalist or materialist but I appreciate that you have some actual nuance on this point

Posted January 27, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Why Ten Reciters but Seven Canonical Readings? — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as comments on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “If there are 10 Quran reciters why were only 7 readings made canonical?”, copied here as written.

Comment 1

Ahruf is a hotly debated concept that goes back to a hadith. It may or may not have any relationship to the Qira’at. There are many theories as to what is meant by the Qur’an being Revealed according to seven ahruf, but they’re all speculative attempts at reconciling the data points. Suyuti thought Ahruf were the lughāt or dialects of the various Arab tribes, Tahawi thought the ahruf referred to permissibility of interchanging loanwords (Yasir Qadhi’s current position), Jazari thought the Ahruf were seven kinds of differences we see in the Qira’at now. Some scholars thought the Uthmanic codices perserved all seven, others thought he chose one and burnt the other six (al-Dani).

I personally like the view that Ahruf just refers to Huruf and that the Ahruf are seven letters that are pronounced in some Arabic dialects but not others. Sibawayh discusses these additional letters but doesn’t tie them to Quranic Ahruf.

The Qira’at are far less speculative.

There were many prominent qurra. These qurra claimed legitimacy by presenting chains that demonstrated ostensibly their recitation originated with the Prophet. However, it was widely acknowledged & known early on that this simply meant their recitation was according to the Sunnah i.e. broadly valid. It didn’t mean they ascribed every choice to the Prophet themselves.

Some of Qira’at comes from early books if grammar describing how to pronounce letters. In fact many of the Qira’at books quote Sibawayh at length or plagiarize without a reference.

However that only explains the focus on correct pronounciation of letters.

Things like mudud or imalah or maqamat aren’t found in grammar books.

The specific lengths of the mudud seem to originate with ibn Muqla’ but reciters already had a less strict concept of qasr, tawassut, and tul.

Jahili poetry was also recited in a kind of tajwid which was applied to Qira’at.

So the rules of Qira’at com from the Arabic poetic tradition being applied to Quran with perhaps some particularities that might originate with the early Muslims. These rules and styles were eventually codified as Qira’at and as the Muslim empire expanded became very rigid.

Additonally, the Qira’at had to conform to the Uthmanic codex and choices about nahw (vowelization/grammar) had to be valid. We see ibn al-Jazari later saying a qira’ah is valid if: it is in accordance to the Rasm, is grammatically sound, and has a single sahih sanad (chain).

Abu Bakr ibn Mujahid simply chose 7 that he thought were the strongest & most representative, but he also acknowledges the wide ken of acceptable differences. Al-Shatibi centuries later writes Hirz al-Amani that goes on to be the standard versified manual for the seven. Ibn al-Jazari comes later and writes Tayyibat al-Nashr intended to complete Shatibi’s work and add three Qira’at that were still popular despite not being codified earlier.

In fact, until today people study four additional Qira’at that are considered weaker than the ten and not widely recited (Hasan al-Basri, A’mash, Yazidi, Muhaysin).

The Qira’at provide guidance on how to vowelize specific words, the introduction of certain sounds, where certain verses end, the spelling of some words, the pronounciation of others, and a few other issues. Even among traditional scholarship the idea that these all go directly back to the Prophet is a very fringe opinion or is considered uneducated.

The Qira’at are developed out of a scope of license to make the Qur’an easier to recite & to explore valid ranges of meaning that were not precisely handed down.

Posted January 27, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Comment 2

When hadith transmitters narrate hadith with a chain they sometimes insert their own commentary (istidraj), early on outright paraphrasing hadith, and no one would expect them to expound on a hadith exactly like their teacher did. I see the sanad of Qira’at somewhat similar earlier on. Yes it’s Nafi’ gave Warsh permission but does that mean Asbahani accurately reflects how Nafi’ recited? Probably not. The students took liberties because the teachers qualified them as top of their field. We don’t know whether Nafi’ would accept Asbahani’s rendition of Warsh even though his name is associated with it.

Posted January 27, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.