Categories
Gaming

Disco Elysium: Favorite and Least Favorite Moments — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/DiscoElysium, in the thread “Just finished the game for the first time. Absolute cinema. What was your favorite moment and your least enjoyed one?”, copied here as written.

Favorite has to be the entire third act from the tribunal, Iosef the deserter (his dialogue & reasoning), & the phasmid.

Least favorite is also Iosef just because there was no way to kind of piece that together earlier on. The game gets off to a very slow start but is more than worth sticking to.

Read the thread on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Society & Culture

Is Logic Deductive, or Just Induction? — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as comments on r/PhilosophyMemes, in the thread “My current path right now (semi-jokingly).”, copied here as written.

Comment 1

Is there any way to demonstrate that these patterns are truly deductive instead of being inductive? And if we cannot, then isn’t it possible what we call “logic” is overfitting for our observed sampleset and can be proven false at any time (the problem of induction)?

Furthermore there are problems even with classical logic (liar’s paradox, explosion, bivalence) so it isn’t a foolproof system, which you alluded to.

Is it effective? Yes. Does efficacy entail truth? Bot neccesarily

Comment 2

Isn’t what I’m describing exactly what Russell & Whitehead failed to do in Principia Mathematica & what Wittgenstein ultimately concluded is a Quixotic endeavor (though that doesn’t seem to stop the analytics)?

Comment 3

You’re a few steps away from radical skepticism and then (possibly) transcendence

Read the thread on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Ahruf, Qira’at and Variants in the Qur’an — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “All Abrahamic Scriptures have variants. Quran variants don't pose problems. I don't understand why people are saying variants are problematic. Even Muhammad approved all of them.”, copied here as written.

While I commend your effort to understand this issue, there are a few places in your comment which seem to not yet fully grasp what is going on here. You seem to be conflating Ahruf (a theological issue stemming from a hadith that HCM scholars would typically be skeptical of), Qira’at (a historical phenomenon of reading traditions), and the codification of the Uthmanic text (a primarily consonantal text with some dotting/vowelization in particularly ambiguous areas).

It is no mystery to anyone that Qurra, grammatians, theologians, and jurists had preferred readings and did tarjīĥ (comparative analysis/critique) of multiple readings across Qira’at (some that were canonized, others that weren’t).

You seem to think that the differences in Qira’at are significant additions in the form of new words after standardization which is provably historically inaccurate. From Uthman onwards Islamic history is very well documented and there’s no reason to think the Quran changed as drastically as you’re alluding to after Uthman.

The challenge as to the original Quran is squarely within the pre-Uthmanic era, i.e. which of the consonantal & vowelization differences directly came from Muhammad. It doesn’t seem feasible the Prophet read with all of them. However, it also doesn’t seem that this was really a concern of the early Qurra so long as their recitation generally followed a few rules.

Posted September 28, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Muhammad as the “Son of Man”? Maqam Mahmud in Early Athari Theology — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as comments on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “Muhammad as the Son of Man?”, copied here as written.

First comment

I can’t speak to the Son of Man prophecy in the Bible but you did make a mistake with respect to the hadith.

There was a lot of debate in early Athari theology with respect to the concept of “Maqām Mahmūd.” (The Praised Station, the word Mahmud coming from the same trilateral root as Muhammad, Mīm-Ĥa-Dāl)

Al-Isra’ 17:79

And from [part of] the night, pray[1] with it [i.e., recitation of the Qur’ān] as additional [worship] for you; it is expected that[2] your Lord will resurrect you to a praised station. [Maqaman Mahmudan]

There are singular narrations which are maqtu’ (not attributed to the prophet himself) which states that the Maqam Mahmud means the Prophet will sit on the Throne of God.

According to Jon Hoover,

Al-Barbahārī may have been involved in riots that began in 317/929 over interpretation of the divine address to the Prophet Muḥammad ‘Perhaps your Lord will raise you up to a praiseworthy station’ (Q 17: 79). Al-Barbahārī understood this to mean that God would seat Muḥammad on the Throne beside Himself whereas semi-rationalists of the time—including followers of the renowned Qurʾān commentator al-Ṭabarī (d. 310/923)—preferred to interpret this metaphorically as Muḥammad’s right to intercede for grave sinners (Melchert 2012). With the Būyid takeover of Baghdad in 334/945, Ḥanbalī animosities turned against the Shīʿīs as well, and Ḥanbalīs engaged in numerous attacks on Shīʿīs, Kalām theologians, and others well into the seventh/thirteenth century. M. Cook attributes this Ḥanbalī social power to their great numbers and a weakened state. Additionally, with the rise of the Būyids and then later the Saljuq conquest of Baghdad in 447/1055, the Ḥanbalīs and the ʿAbbāsid caliphs found common cause in undermining those foreign rulers (Sabarī 1981: 101–20; Cook 2000: 115–28).

[Cambridge Companion to Islamic Theology, Hanbali Theology, pg. 6]

There were, and still are, a swathe of Muslims whom believe Muhammad will sit on God’s Throne on the Day of Judgement. Over time it has been rendered a minority view in Islamic theology, and even most Atharis/Hanbalis today do not consider it a primary point of contention, but it’s there.

Of course this was never interpreted to suggest the level of power or divinity that your understanding of the Biblical “Son of Man” entails.

Posted September 21, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Follow-up comment

Your argument is predicated on the historicity of the Son of Man claims in the Old Testament and the New Testament, believing that they do apply to Jesus, and that Muslims recognize the historicity of those two texts. This argument can only come from a Christian theological background. A Jew, for example, would not argue that Jesus is the Son of Man and their text is older than the New Testament. In which case, a Jew would argue that you accept the Torah, the Torah definitely does not indicate that Jesus is the Son of Man, and in fact Jesus cannot be a prophet according to Judaic law.

So your argument is a theological one, not a historical one. Even if you yourself subscribe to Christian theology, that’s fine, but at least present some robust argumentation here.

Posted September 22, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Literalism, Metaphor and Cognition: A Question for Islamic Studies — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as comments on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “AMA with Abdullah Ansar. I work on early Islamic intellectual history, cognitive science, Qurʾānic studies, Shīʿī traditions, and Ḥadīth transmission.”, copied here as written.

Comment 1

Hey Abdullah thanks for this AMA.

I have an armchair theory about cognitive science & Islamic studies that I’d love to get your take on.

It seems to me there is some kind of an analytic versus syncretic gradient in cognition which is mostly either culturally or biologically or developmentally informed? However this gradient seems to impact cognition and specifically interpretative work.

For example the Sifat controversy across Islamic thought. Why do some people lean towards literalism naturally versus metaphorical meanings of texts?

I see this pattern everywhere, in every human endeavor, but I’m not sure how it could be quantified or studied in any objective manner (or if the thesis could be validated or invalidated).

What are your thoughts? Is there a developmental or cognitive component to the degree of literalism or atomistic thinking a person is naturally inclined towards?

Comment 2

This is perfect. Exactly what I’ve been thinking about. Going to give it a read but glad to see it is a real observed phenomenon

Originally posted on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Images of Living Things in Islamic Law — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/BookshelvesDetective, in the thread “Need more space”, copied here as written.

Depictions of living things are not seen as “blasphemy” even in the strictest schools of Islamic jurisprudence.

Primarily the Hanbali school, although scholars from other schools, prohibited depicting living things that have a soul on the basis of a narration of a Prophetic companion ibn ‘Abbas wherein he saw a painter at the marketplace and told him that the Prophet Muhammad said,

Every maker of graven images will be in Hellfire. Every image he made will be given a soul to punish him in Hell.

Ibn Abbas interpreted this broadly to mean any depiction of a living thing with a soul (i.e. animals).

However, blasphemy would be akin to shirk (polytheism), kufr (disbelief), or nifaq (hypocrisy). Merely creating an image, despite how stern the hadith may seem, in no way rises to that level.

It is moreso akin to a minor sin, with the strictest possible interpretation being that it is a major sin.

Based on the wording of this narration however most scholars disagreed with ibn Abbas and took the meaning of craven images to be images pertaining to idolatry specifically.

Posted September 16, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

What Can Historians Know About Early Readings of These Verses? — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “Academically speaking, what are the possible meanings of Quranic mentions of Allah's "hands," "eyes," "face," and so on? Did early Muslims and Muslim theologians understand them literally or figuratively? How do academics understand those mentions?”, copied here as written.

There is not enough historical evidence to know how early Muslims or even the Quranic Author interpreted these Verses. Considering that some of these expressions seem to be figures of speech, others seem to be more literal, it seems more likely that the Quranic Author & the immediate audience did not focus on the anthropomorphic versus literal debate. It was not on their radar, so to speak.

When Muslim scholars began coming into contact with practitioners of other faiths or scholars of other milleus, they were exposed to debates and ideas from their intellectual traditions. That’s not to say much of the anthropomorphic versus literal debate is not indigenous to the Islamic tradition, but it did not happen in a vaccum.

This seems to be moreso a question of cognitive orientation and the philosophy of language than even an Islamic or historical question. Why do some people, broadly speaking, interpret words more literally? Why do others interpret them more figuratively?

This question spans cultures and, while the Sifat controversy is a microcosm, I don’t believe is the first or only battleground.

Quite simply, if the early Muslims or the Quranic Author had an opinion on literalism/anthropomorphism versus figurative/metaphorical depictions of God’s “body parts” as rendered in the Quran – it just isn’t clear from the sources. I would go so far as to say it isn’t even clear in the Sunni corpus, taking the historicity of hadith for granted, let alone the corpus that HCM academics consider to be reliable.

We don’t see these discussions in Islamic history until shortly before the time of the Mu’tazilah, when we know that especially near Eastern Greco-Roman influenced Christian theology & philosophy was already being grappled with.

The fact that the apocryphal story of Jahm b. Safwan states he apostated after engaging with Buddhists and used rationalist to return to Islam, founding “Jahmism”, is very telling. Whether or not the story is true, the idea that Muslim intellectuals were grappling with intellectual traditions posing these problems and having to come up with solutions may indicate that a lot of these “Islamic” debates are far reaching

Edit:

u/abdullah_ansar was able to point me in the direction of:

Esteban Freidin and Luz Acera Martini, “An Analytic Cognitive Style Negatively Predicts a More Literal but Not a More Symbolic Religiosity Type,” The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion 32, no. 1 (2022): 31–52, https://doi.org/10.1080/10508619.2020.1868197.

Posted September 15, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Society & Culture

Does Science Work Because It Is True? — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/PhilosophyMemes, in the thread “No acausal mechanisms in the brain? No problem.”, copied here as written.

Yes a typo on my part. Richard Dawkins famously, ignorantly, gaffed that science is true because it works.

Efficacy is not truth. It’s just that simple. If you want to operate solely on efficacy you can do so, but you have to give up claims of absolute or objective truth.

It seems like your argument is that objective truth is irrelevant because we can only evaluate efficacy but that’s not the case at all. Even within an empirical framework you can evaluate truth outside of efficacy, albiet to a far more limited extent than in philosophy.

You’re basically arguing, “why should we do philosophy at all if science works?” the answer is that science cannot lead to objective truth and is itself dependent on a philosophical framework which must be justified for you to ever reach the conclusion that the natural sciences “work.”

You have the benefit of inheriting that framework as a part of cultural hegemony & capitalist realism, but it is predicated on a lot of assumptions & axioms. Even if you are unaware or choose not to acknowledge them, you’re still accepting an entire philosophical framework.

I am telling you that I have evaluated this default, capitalist realist/culturally hegemonic, secular empirical framework, and found it lacking. You’re saying “but science works so that’s all that matters” without realizing that science cannot just “work” in a vacuum without that assumption stack.

Posted September 13, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Follow-up replies in the same thread

I don’t see what Agrippa or Munchausen have to do with anything. Physicalism and materialism require an entire weltanschauung underpinning them and don’t exist in a vacuum. Your non-engagement with that philosophical tradition doesn’t mean your worldview is either coherent or accurate, just because science has efficacy. The efficacy of natural sciences is the last step in a long line of philosophical assumptions, and is itself problematic due to the black swan & problem of induction, non-reproducibility of many scientific studies, and deeper issues of radical skepticism.

Again, not sure how the Agrippan trilemma is relevant here at all.

The “now what” is you need a transcendental philosophical tether or you go into radical skepticism or you concede that you want to have an irrational anti-philosophical worldview because you personally are not that invested in truth. That’s why Ghazali & Decartes went down the radical skeptical path and then chose a metaphysical “God” to tether their epistemology onto, because the choices are either: don’t do philosophy and have a poorly thought out worldview (seems to be your approach) or accept radical skepticism

You’ve taken the physical world as axiomatic when it is among the least justifiable axioms philosophically speaking. Almost everything that is one level or higher more abstract is better justified. You don’t understand what metaphysics, epistemology, or ontology are

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Society & Culture

Can You Be Both a Marxist and a Kantian? — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/PhilosophyMemes, in the thread “Meme & Genuine: Can I Be Both Marxist and Kantian or Am I Stupid?”, copied here as written.

Marxism is predicated upon materialism. If you are an idealist, you could agree with some of Marx’s conclusions, but not the method. If Marx is wrong about materialism as a bootstrap, then there are more important things in the noumenon than the historical material conditions of the underclasses.

You could be an idealist and agree with his critique of capital, but I don’t think you could be an idealist and agree with dialectical materialism.

Originally posted on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Why Follow a Madhhab? The Doctor Analogy — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/islam, in the thread “Why Can’t We Just Identify as Muslims Instead of Following a Madhhab?”, copied here as written.

Let’s ask a different question:

Would you go to a doctor who refused to tell anyone what university they studied medicine at?

You, as a person in need of a doctor, don’t need to identify as a graduate of Harvard medical school or John Hopkins or any other medical school.

However, you surely want evidence that your doctor has studied medicine in a systematic fashion so you can trust his prescriptions.

Din is the same way. As a layman, you don’t need to identify as following “Harvard’s medical curriculum” or a particular madh’hab. But when you need a ruling, you want to make sure the person giving it is properly licensed to do so. In Islamic law, the institutions that properly license someone are the madhahib.

If you decide you want to actually study in a serious way, you don’t go and take 101 level courses at 4 universities. Someone who is a freshman at 4 different schools doesn’t get a degree. You pick one school and continue until you get a bachelor’s, master’s, or PhD.

Similarly, when you are ready to take fiqh more seriously, you pick a madh’hab and study it.

The madhahib are not personalities or sects or identifiers, and some extremists do take them as such. They are schools to systematically study law.

If you felt very ill, would you trust yourself to conduct independent online research to treat yourself? Or your parents? Or your children?

Or would you rather have a qualified doctor take a look?

That’s the same thing with Islamic rulings and evidence. The layman can spend all day researching Quran & hadith online, just like you can look up pharmaceuticals & research papers. That will never replace 8 years of university plus residency to become an actual MD. Similarly, online research of Islamic sources will never replace an 8 year alim program plus independent scholarly study.

Originally posted on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.