Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Rhyme, Recitation and the Written Text of the Qur’an — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “six Quranic rhymes that were lost due to adherence to the written text”, copied here as written.

I do agree there are alterations made to words for poetic reasons but these are inconsistently applied by both the scribes & the readers. A great example is the hā al-sakt in the Qira’ah of Ya’qub.

Continuous reading is not rare.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=k2FAdK-zKEY&pp=ygUi2LPZiNix2Kkg2KfZhNin2YbYtNmC2KfZgiDZiNi12YTYpw%3D%3D

These Verses are especially read with Wasl in Tarawih during Ramadan.

I don’t understand what method you’re using to determine these “hidden” rhymes other than that a few stand out to you but people have been reading the rhymes you mentioned in Qira’ah Wasl/Hadr for as long as we have documentation of that.

Posted August 31, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Why the Qur’an Criticizes Calling Scholars Lords — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “The Talmud has many figures called "my son" by God so why does the Quran single Eliezer Ben Hycarnus?”, copied here as written.

If we take the hadith of ‘Adi bin Hatim to have historical value, then the Qur’anic criticism of taking their monks & rabbis (ahbarahum wa ruhbanahum) as lords other than Allah was tied to legislative Lordship (Hakimiyyah), not direct deification. In Rabbinic tradition the Haver (Hibr in Arabic) has legislative authority, as a Talmudic “son of god.”

Therefore, the jurisprudential prominence of Eliezer & his capacity to legislate independently of Allah as a “son of god” constitutes a kind of legal deification. This is contrasted with the Christian theological deification.

It seems that the Quran is in discourse with statements of Eliezer that we can find in the Mishnah, just as it seems it is in discourse with Jacob of Serugh (or at least the traditions surrounding both figures).

Posted August 12, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Gaming

Disco Elysium: Dros and the Dread of Building a Better World

A reading of Disco Elysium, adapted from a discussion of its ending. Spoilers follow.

Dros is what happens when someone believes they are approaching something perfect only to lose it. Which is really what the entire game is about, moving past utopianism to the dread of slowly building a better world. Harry's utopia was Dora (symbolized by the accusedly perfect Innocence Dolores Dei).

Instead of Dros accepting that the communist revolution of Revachol failed but that very left wing forces still needed support, he calcified. As did Harry in losing Dora, as did the monarchists, fascists, moralists, etc.

The main characters in Disco Elysium are not actively taking practical measures to improve their world, they are either stagnant or regressing.

Dros is a perfect final boss because he is the culmination of believing that "The historic opportunity for a revolution has passed. It will not come back anymore. However hard I try, whatever I do."

Nothing Harry does will rewind the clock and bring Dora back to him. Nothing Dros does will bring back the revolution.

This is contrasted with the phasmid, a very Sufi or taoist figure who is "weightless." When it loses a limb, it tears it off and regrows it.

"You are a violent and irrepressible miracle. The vaccum of cosmos and the stars burning in it are afraid of you. Given enough time you would wipe us all out and replace us with nothing – just by accident."

The phasmid then tells you to turn away from the ruin (the relationship with Dora) and do it for the working class.

I am astounded at the amount of pain that must have informed the ending of Disco Elysium, between the dream of Dolores Dei and Iosef Dros the Deserter. It's the pain of profound earthshattering heartbreak and decimated political ambition and lost hope. But the conversation with the phasmid is so beautiful and profound, demonstrating that it is the way of nature to suffer such grievances yet evolve and thrive.


This began as a comment I wrote on Reddit. Read it in context here: https://www.reddit.com/r/DiscoElysium/comments/1vknc7u/yeah_id_say_that_pretty_accurate/p34jlcq/

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Do Any Sunnis Reject the Uprightness of the Companions? — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “Is there any Sunni sect that rejects Adalat al-Sahabah (Arabic: عدالة الصحابة)”, copied here as written.

Orthodox Sunnism acknowledges that some of the sahabah were hypocrites, such as Abdullah ibn Ubayy, but asserts that the sahabah as a class are saved and should not be criticized. This doesn’t mean that some Sunni scholars were not farther on the spectrum of Tashayyu’ or preferring Ali and critiquing Mu’awiyyah – such as al-Nasa’i. However, you’re not going to find a Sunni scholar calling Mu’awiyyah or his partisans a hypocrite as the boundaries of Sunnism are partially defined by holding the opposing doctrine.

By the time Sunnism exists historically, it is defined by upholding the uprightness of the sahabah.

Posted August 2, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Systems & Technology

Notes on Codex Performance and Agentic Token Use

I have been suffering with the reduced token limits lately along with major performance issues with the Codex app. However, after this latest reset, I am able to use 5.6 Luna mid to… actually get a lot of work done?

It's still burning through tokens like nobody's business but it's no longer spawning hundreds of useless agents that bog my computer down and I'm rapidly completing threads.

Has anyone noticed this after the latest reset?

I was burning through the $100 plan in 3 days and likely will still, but it was also getting nothing done and making my computer unusable while it worked. Now it's accomplishing quite a bit.


Originally posted by Ali Shukri Amin on Reddit. Read or join the discussion here: https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1v92f5c/major_performance_improvement/

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Did Early Islamic Scholars Believe Prophets Could Err? — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “Did early Islamic scholars believe that prophets could make mistakes?”, copied here as written.

Total infallibility may have been an Ash’arite development as Ash’arites argued that Prophets must be totally reliable with respect to dispersing religious knowledge. This formula is exemplified in beginner Ash’ari works such as ibn Ashir’s al-Murshid al-Mu’in.

Revivalist Athari ibn Taymiyyah argued that Prophets were, in fact, capable of sin based on Qur’anic texts and hadith.

I don’t think early Islamic scholars discussed this issue in depth, leading to Ash’aris developing the concept of total infallibility (besides non-sinful mistakes or choosing the lesser of two good options; khilāf al-ūla) and later Atharis, following ibn Taymiyyah, pushing back on this concept.

When Mohammad ibn Abd al-Wah’hab included a hadith that suggests Adam & Hawa fell into shirk to explain a verse of the Qur’an in his Kitab al-Tawhid, Ash’aris went so far as to imply that including such a hadith is tantamount to shirk itself. The reasoning being that the infallibility (isma) of the Prophets in religious issues implicates their reliability in relaying religious knowledge. If Adam, or any other prophet, was capable of shirk – none of the prophets are “reliable.”

Posted July 21, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

How Ibn Taymiyya Became So Influential — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “Ibn Taymiyya was considered a fringe scholar in his day. How did he become so widely respected today?”, copied here as written.

Your question & post should be reframed. While ibn Taymiyyah had less historical influence than he does today, that doesn’t make him “fringe.” It also doesn’t mean there is a straight line between ibn Taymiyyah & modern Salafism.

If anything, ibn Taymiyyah was an extremely successful scholar in his time. We do not know much about the vast majority of Islamic scholars throughout history, if we even know their names and that they were scholars. Even scholars whose texts are still studied to this day often have scant biographical information.

Not only do we know a lot about ibn Taymiyyah himself, he was a prolific author, and the vast majority of his thought was preserved. He had many students, engaged in military campaigns, was important enough to imprison 4 times, was famous enough that ibn Batutta knew who he was, and his funeral was famously well attended.

After his death, he became widely acknowledged as a lesser mujtahid in the Hanbali madh’hab – perhaps the 4th or 5th most important authority on fiqh. His views on Aqidah were not widely studied, but he was seen as a preeminent scholar.

There’s a reason Mohammed ibn Abd al-Wahhab even heard of ibn Taymiyyah and his student ibn al-Qayyim, and it’s not because they were fringe.

That being said, ibn Taymiyyah attempted to reconstruct all of Islamic theology in a new light that he claimed would disprove didactic theology (Ash’ari Kalam). By developing his own theory of linguistics and applying it to Arabic, ibn Taymiyyah attempted to revive the radical literalism of early Hanbali thought and reframe it in an advanced philosophical fashion.

Believe it or not, ibn Taymiyyah’s political & governmental thinking is perhaps some of his least controversial. Besides his incitement of rebellion against the Mongal Ilkhanate (which the Seljuks supported), ibn Taymiyyah was primarily maligned for his abstract theological (istighatha, Sifat) and practical jurisprudential views (triple talaq).

Salafism relies upon ibn Taymiyyah because he is most robust iconoclast against Asharism, istighatha, contemporary Tasawuff, taqlid, etc. However, Salafism is a movement while ibn Taymiyyah was a person. Later scholars took aspects of ibn Taymiyyah they liked while often contradicting others.

Mohammed ibn Abd al-Wah’hab codified the istighatha views of ibn Taymiyyah while also adding his own system to define the boundaries of Islam and excommunicate (takfir) others. While the politics of Mohammed ibn Abd al-Wahhab are highly problematic within Muslim circles, the politics of ibn Taymiyyah and ibn Abd al-Wahhab are broadly aligned with the rest of Sunnism on how to deal with non-Muslim political bodies (ahkam al-sultaniyyah).

If you are talking about the philosophy of language, the Attributes of God, ontology, saint worship, tawassul, or particular rulings of fiqh – ibn Taymiyyah held unique views on all of those. However, if you are talking about unprecedented geopolitical positions, you’re better off discussing Mohammed ibn Abd al-Wahhab.

Modern Salafism is broadly speaking a product of early Hanbali thought, some Taymiyyan influence, ibn Abd al-Wahhab, and some influence from modernist thinkers (Rashid Rida, Albani in his rejection of fiqh). It is less a philosophical movement and the istighatha issue is for all practical purposes irrelevant today (the practice is mostly eradicated).

Posted July 13, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Beginner Books on Sufism — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/MuslimAcademics, in the thread “Best Beginner Books Gentle introductions to Sufism”, copied here as written.

This seems to be moreso a hodgepodge of random Sufi literature of varying degrees of importance and difficulty.

Tasawuff & Adab are the twin sciences of Ihsan. The major topics of Sufism are:

  1. Taqwa
  2. Inabah (tawba & istighfar)
  3. Diseases of the heart & its cures
  4. Ishārah (the spiritual implications of outward things)

Whereas the major topics of Adab are grouped moreso by who the adab is towards.

For a practical overview of Tasawuff, the Firdous Ltd. compilations Purification of the Soul & Heaven’s Door are some of the best I’ve seen.

The Book of Assistance by al-Haddad is great as a practical manual.

On diseases of the heart & cures, check the commentary on Mohammad Mawlud’s Purification of the Soul done by the Tayba foundation. It is far superior to Hamza Yusuf’s.

Ibn al-Jawzi’s abridgement of al-Ihya is far more approachable and contains a lot of improvements. It’s called Minhaj al-Qasidin.

If you’re looking for a comprehensive overview, AnneMarie Schimmel’s The Mystical Dimensions of Islam is comprehensive for its time.

For adab, sidi Zarruq has al-Nasiha al-Kafiyyah which discusses the adab towards Allah, his prophet, and the Ummah. Mohammed Mawlud has incredible adab texts on the Prohibitions of the Tongue, the Rights of the Parents, and the Adab of the Masjid.

Ihya is considered an advanced text & is studied with commentaries like Safinat al-Najat. Another advanced text is shaykh al-Islam al-Harawi’s Manazil al-Sa’irin, the most famous commentary being ibn al-Qayyim’s Madarij al-Salikin.

The last component of Ihsan is Hikmah (traditional Islamic medicine).

Supplemental Sufi literature includes Sufi poetry, like Rumi or Farid al-Din al-‘Attar.

It should be noted that theological Sufism & Sunni Sufism are distinct although intertwined. Most Sunni Sufis don’t rely on ibn Arabi for example.

Posted June 7, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Abraham, the Dream and the Rejection of Human Sacrifice — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/MuslimAcademics, in the thread “Abraham, the Dream, and the Rejection of Human Sacrifice”, copied here as written.

This is less severe of a reinterpretation than ibn ‘Arabi’s, who argued that Ibrahim wholly misunderstood the dream. I think the problem with this interpretation is that Allah clearly intended for Ibrahim to intepret the ru’ya as he did. The story is not just about the sanctity of human life.

We also lose the rich insights that come from Ibrahim intending to sacrifice his son, such as discussions around the teleological suspension of the ethical and the necesity of submitting everything to Allah even when we cannot justify it with our limited intellect.

Some of the best that has ever been written on this topic was by Kierkegaard in Fear & Trembling.

In fact, the preservation of life is NOT the greatest goal of the Shari’ah. The preservation of Din is. Once Ibrahim had proven his Din & the Din of his son preserved, THEN the maqsad became to preserve life.

Posted May 30, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

The Qur’an Makes Testable Claims — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/MuslimAcademics, in the thread “Question for everyone here”, copied here as written.

The Qur’an provides testable claims. If the claims are true, Islam is true. If the claims are false, Islam is false.

One of the central claims it makes is that there’s only One God & it goes on to describe in a lot of detail who God is (Tawhid). So does that align with reality? If the Quran is the only book accurately describing what we know about God from reality and it claims God sent this Book that’s extremely compelling.

Islam is the most coherent, easy to accept, rational, palatable, worldview that is consistent with the observable world, mind, intuition, logic, and withstands skeptical critique.

Nothing else comes close to making sense.

Atheism is based on an unprovable claim, contradiction intuition, undermining all rational thought (logical nihilism), and cannot answer solipsism/the Boltzmann brain problem.

Whereas, belief in Tawḥīd is axiomatic.

God doesn’t need to be proven someone needs to come up with some evidence we should contradict our intuitions. That evidence also needs to account for issues like solipsism.

The Quran is an internally coherent text that is historical and makes several claims which we can determine to be true. The Quranic conceptualization of God is true. The Quranic claims about prophet Muhammad seem true. The Quranic theories about society and civilization ring true.

Another major claim is that the Quran is guidance for mankind. Let’s test it.

In the Quran we find a unique intersection between epic poetry, founding mythology, legal code, theological/philosophical discourse, history, and song in the Quran.

The Bible which has several books, some of which are law, others founding myth, others performative music (Hebrew psalms), some theological discourse, etc. But it’s much more segmented. Western tradition also doesn’t identify the Bible as an epic poem, use it as the basis of legal code, or have it as a central shared piece of music.

It’s also a geopolitical, cultural, and civilizational text. The Quran still holds supreme importance for billions of people, holding the roles that spiritual music, shared history, constitutional law, origin myths, poetry, basis of philosophical outlook, and day-to-day morals.

Muslims see the Quran like: the Odyssey, Biblical Genesis, the US Constitution, Herodotus’ Histories, their greatest opera, Confucian practical wisdom, Nichomachean ethics, and spiritual catechisms/koans. Where a student of Western classics and literature would access 10 texts, or listen to a poem, or attend an opera, to draw from their tradition – religious Muslims invariably first return to the Quran.

I don’t know of any other one text that currently features so prominently in the mind of so many people in such a way.

For one book to spontaneously arrive in the Arabian desert and constitute an entire paradigm singularly can be accurately described as “Revelation”

There is no one book in all of documented human history with the kind of outsized influence as the Quran, which is one of it’s major thesis.

The third major claim, besides Tawhid & the Quran being Hidaya, is that Muhammad is rasulAllah. Since prophet Muhammad got Tawhid right & has the Quran, which is Hidaya, this third claim is also proven.

Posted May 25, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.