Categories
Islamic Scholarship

“Where Is Allah?” Transcendence and the Classical Debate

A companion to my video on the question “Where is Allah?” This gives the classical background; the full treatment is in the video, linked below.

Few short questions in Islamic theology carry as much weight as this one. It is not idle curiosity about location; it is a doorway into how Muslims have understood God’s transcendence, His attributes, and the limits of language about the divine.

The narration behind the question

The phrasing traces to a well-known hadith in which the Prophet ﷺ asks a servant-woman “Where is Allah?” and, on her answering that He is above, affirms her belief. That report has been a touchstone in creedal discussion for centuries, precisely because it seems to license a particular kind of answer while raising obvious questions about how such language should be understood.

The Atharī reading

In the Atharī tradition, the report is taken to affirm God’s ʿuluww — His highness, His being above His creation — alongside the Qur’anic language of istiwāʾ over the Throne. The characteristic move is to affirm what the texts affirm, in the manner that befits God, without asking “how” (bilā kayf) and without likening Him to created things that occupy space.

The alternative readings

Other Sunni schools — the Ashʿarīs and Māturīdīs — have approached the same texts differently, either consigning the precise meaning to God (tafwīḍ) or interpreting the apparent spatial language figuratively (taʾwīl), out of concern to guard divine transcendence against any hint of corporeality. The disagreement is old, serious, and conducted among scholars who all affirm that God is unlike His creation.

Why the framing matters

Much of the modern argument about this question generates heat because it collapses the careful distinctions the tradition drew — between affirming an attribute and specifying its modality, between transcendence and figurative language. Laying those distinctions back out is most of the work, and it is what I take up in the video.


This accompanies my video discussion. Watch on YouTube, or see the original post here: https://www.reddit.com/r/aliamin/comments/1ldvh9o/

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Does Hell Mean God Is Cruel? An Islamic Response

A companion to my video responding to the question, “Does Hell mean God is cruel?” The framing is here; the full response is in the video, linked below.

The objection is familiar and it is not frivolous: if God is infinitely merciful, how can there be a Hell — and how can finite wrongdoing draw unending punishment? Taken seriously rather than waved away, the question opens onto some of the deepest matters in Islamic theology.

Reframing the terms

Part of the work is noticing what the objection assumes. It tends to treat punishment as raw vengeance, and mercy and justice as opposites — as if any punishment at all were a failure of mercy. The Islamic tradition does not grant either assumption. Justice and mercy are both divine perfections, not competing forces to be traded off; and punishment is framed in terms of desert, consequence, and the moral seriousness of turning away from God, not in terms of divine cruelty.

Mercy as the wider horizon

The tradition insists, on strong textual grounds, that God’s mercy outstrips His wrath — that mercy is the encompassing default and punishment the exception carved out by human choice. That ordering matters: it means the burden of Hell falls on sustained, knowing refusal, not on ordinary human frailty, which mercy and forgiveness are everywhere said to meet.

The question of duration

On the hardest sub-question — the endlessness of the Fire — the tradition is not monolithic. There is a serious minority discussion, associated with figures like Ibn Taymiyya and Ibn al-Qayyim, about whether the punishment of Hell is in some sense finite in duration for at least some of its inhabitants. That this conversation exists within the tradition, rather than outside it, already tells against the caricature of a theology indifferent to the worry.

Where it lands

None of this “solves” the problem of Hell the way one solves an equation; it is meant to show that the charge of cruelty rests on assumptions the tradition never accepted, and that the alternative is not a God who punishes gladly but one whose mercy is primary and whose justice is real. That is the case I make in the video.


This accompanies my video discussion. Watch on YouTube, or see the original post here: https://www.reddit.com/r/aliamin/comments/1ldvi4h/

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

The Sahifa of Hammam ibn Munabbih and the Early Writing of Hadith

A companion to my video on the Ṣaḥīfa of Hammām ibn Munabbih. The background is here; the video is linked below.

One of the recurring debates about hadith concerns when the reports were written down — whether they floated for generations as pure oral memory before being committed to paper, or whether written records ran alongside oral transmission from very early on. The Ṣaḥīfa of Hammām ibn Munabbih is one of the most important pieces of evidence in that discussion.

What it is

The Ṣaḥīfa is a small early collection — a single “page” or booklet — of reports that Hammām ibn Munabbih (d. c. 101/719) took from the Companion Abū Hurayra, whose student he was. It preserves on the order of a hundred and forty narrations, transmitted as a discrete unit.

Why it matters

Its significance is documentary. Because it can be placed with a first-century transmitter writing directly from a Companion, it offers concrete evidence that hadith were being fixed in written form within the first century of Islam — not only carried in memory and set down centuries later. And when the contents of this early written unit are compared with the same reports as they appear in later canonical collections, the degree of stability in the wording is itself a data point about how carefully the material was transmitted.

The larger point

Documents like the Ṣaḥīfa shift the burden in the “oral versus written” debate. They do not by themselves settle every question about authenticity, but they make it harder to assume, as a default, that early hadith transmission was purely oral and therefore maximally unstable. That is the thread I develop in the video.


This accompanies my video discussion. Watch on YouTube, or see the original post here: https://www.reddit.com/r/aliamin/comments/1ldvgvk/

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

The Most Authentic Book of Hadith: What Stands Behind the Claim

A companion to my video on the most authentic book of hadith. Background here; the full discussion is linked below.

When Sunni Muslims call a book “the most authentic after the Qur’an,” they mean the Ṣaḥīḥ of Muḥammad ibn Ismāʿīl al-Bukhārī (d. 256/870). The claim is strong, and it is worth understanding what stands behind it rather than repeating it as a slogan.

Who al-Bukhārī was

Al-Bukhārī was a hadith master of extraordinary memory and, more importantly, extraordinary rigor. He is reported to have sifted a vast body of circulating reports down to a comparatively small number that met his standard, arranging them not at random but under legal and theological chapter-headings — the tarājim — whose wording often carries his own juristic argument.

What made his criteria demanding

His threshold went beyond the common requirement of an unbroken chain of upright, precise narrators. He is understood to have insisted, for a report to enter the Ṣaḥīḥ, on established contemporaneity and actual meeting between successive narrators in the chain — not merely the possibility that they could have met. That extra condition, stricter than some of his peers required, is a large part of why his collection acquired its standing.

Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim and the pairing

Alongside it stands the Ṣaḥīḥ of Muslim ibn al-Ḥajjāj, his younger contemporary, prized for its careful arrangement of the variant wordings of a single report. Together the two are the Ṣaḥīḥayn, the twin pillars on which much of Sunni hadith scholarship rests.

What the claim does and does not mean

“Most authentic book” is a statement about the aggregate reliability of a collection assembled under exacting conditions; it is not a claim that every judgment within it is beyond discussion, and the tradition itself has always contained careful conversation about particular narrators and reports. Holding both of those together — the high standing and the living scholarly discussion — is the honest way to talk about the book, and it is what I try to do in the video.


This accompanies my video discussion. Watch on YouTube, or see the original post here: https://www.reddit.com/r/aliamin/comments/1ldvg1k/

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

The History of Atharism

This companion piece accompanies my video on the history of Atharism. It sketches the background; the fuller argument is in the video, linked below.

“Atharī” comes from athar — a narration, a transmitted report. As a name for a theological orientation it points to a commitment: that in matters of creed, the transmitted sources come first, and reason serves them rather than sitting in judgment over them. But Atharism is not a timeless label dropped ready-made into history. It has a story, and telling that story carefully changes how the position is understood.

Origins in the Ahl al-Ḥadīth

The roots lie with the early Ahl al-Ḥadīth, the partisans of hadith, who in the first Islamic centuries resisted the growing use of speculative theology (kalām) to settle questions about God, His attributes, and the created or uncreated status of the Qur’an. Their instinct was to affirm what scripture affirms and to refrain where scripture is silent — to hold the divine attributes as they are given, without stripping them of meaning (taʿṭīl) and without likening God to creation (tashbīh).

The crucible of the Miḥna

This orientation was forged under pressure. The Miḥna — the inquisition instituted in the third/ninth century over the doctrine of the created Qur’an — made the stakes concrete. Aḥmad ibn Ḥanbal’s refusal to concede the point, at real personal cost, turned a scholarly tendency into a recognizable creed with a hero and a memory. Much of what later gets called Atharī consolidates around that episode and the figure at its center.

Systematization and afterlife

What began as a disposition — a reluctance to over-theorize — was later given more systematic articulation, most influentially by Ibn Taymiyya and his students, who argued that the early community’s reticence was itself a coherent method rather than a failure to philosophize. That later systematization is part of the history too, and it is worth asking how faithfully it maps onto the earlier disposition it claims to continue.

Why the history matters

Reading Atharism historically, rather than as a static box on a chart of sects, does two things. It takes the position seriously as a considered method rather than a mere refusal to think; and it keeps us honest about development, about the distance between an early instinct and its later theorization. That is the thread I follow in the video.


This accompanies my video discussion. Watch on YouTube, or see the original post here: https://www.reddit.com/r/aliamin/comments/1ldvgd6/

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Istighatha & Tawassul: A Series on Seeking Aid and Nearness to God

Few subjects in contemporary Muslim discourse generate more heat and less light than istighātha (seeking aid) and tawassul (seeking a means of nearness to God). The debate is old, but it is usually conducted with slogans rather than sources. This series is my attempt to slow the argument down: to define the terms carefully, read the primary evidence on its own terms, and bring newer tools — including modern epigraphic research on pre-Islamic Arabian religion — to bear on questions that are too often settled by assertion.

The series runs across written pieces and video episodes. I am collecting the parts here so they can be followed in order, and linking each back to where the discussion is happening.

The series

  1. Introduction — Istighātha & Tawassul, Part 1: framing the question and why the usual framing fails.
  2. Definitions — Part 2: what the terms actually mean, and the distinctions that most arguments skip.
  3. The Religion of Quraysh — Part 4: what the pre-Islamic Arabs actually believed and did, and why it matters for the charge of shirk.
  4. Is Istighātha & Tawassul Shirk? A New Perspective: the central question, argued from the sources.
  5. A New Analysis Using Modern Epigraphic Research: bringing the inscriptional record of Arabian religion into the discussion.
  6. Episode 16 — What Yasir Qadhi Doesn’t Understand About the Question: a direct engagement with a prominent contemporary treatment.

Method, briefly

The wager of the series is that this is not, at bottom, a shouting match between “pro” and “anti” camps. It is a question of classical juristic method: what the terms denote, what the Qur’anic condemnation of the mushrikūn was actually condemning, and whether the modern polemical category maps onto the historical one. Get the definitions and the history right, and much of the heat dissipates.

New parts are added as they are written or recorded. Video episodes are on my YouTube channel; the written threads are linked above.

Categories
Film & Television

The Best-Written Art of the 21st Century? — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/writingscaling, in the thread “What do you consider the best-written piece of art of the 21st century, across any artform?”, copied here as written.

I’m not sure about that. It would be an incredibly compelling novel as well. I think the lead author struggles with that linear medium, hence his Terrible & Sacred Air not being comparable to Disco Elysium. But were we to somehow transpose the qualities & profundity of Disco into literature, it has material insights into the human condition expressed in a way unique enough to be considered a contribution to fine literature.

That being said, I have yet to see a single online analysis that I think “gets” some of the narrative turns, especially in the last quarter. There is a lot left to be said about Disco.

Posted September 9, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Slavery, Terminology and Fātimid Egypt — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as comments on r/AcademicQuran, in the thread “Black Eunuchs, Slave Soldiers and Concubines in Fātimid Egypt”, copied here as written.

Comment 1

Is there a worthwhile distinction to be made with respect to political systems that afforded slaves some degree of either autonomy or a pathway to political agency versus ones that required violent revolution for former slaves to have any say? I see what you are saying about slaves being miscast as entirely passive actors and why that is obviously untrue in nearly every context, do you think it is problematic to differentiate between for example American antebellum slavery and the Ottoman devshirme system of slavery?

Comment 2

I almost feel like using the single term slave and not a set of conjunct terms makes it harder to discuss the varied, complicated, aspects of these various historical subjugative frameworks. Keeping the term for its negative connotations is important but if there were an easier way to distinguish for nonexperts among the various main modes, may be easier to have discourse?

Comment 3

Are you familiar with Siddharth Kara? Slavery exists today in a literal way, it’s just buried within supply chains as opposed to being directly perceptible. In many ways, globalization has allowed privileged countries to maintain a base of slaves but offshore the horrors.

Marxist thinkers would also argue for the concept of wage slavery which further problematizes using just the word “slave” IMO. It becomes harder to demarcate when something may meet the definition you defined above but is not socially perceived as slavery.

Originally posted on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Why God Is Eternal but the Cosmos Is Not — Ali Shukri Amin

By Ali Shukri Amin. I first wrote this as a comment on r/MuslimCorner, in the thread “Why do we allow God to be an eternal, uncreated reality, but refuse to allow the universe to be an eternal, uncreated reality? Couldn't the universe simply be the thing that has always existed, and then everything including us came from it?”, copied here as written.

The cosmos (all potential universes) does not exhibit the properties of something that is either eternal or uncreated. The simplest problem with an eternal universe is tasalsul (infinite regression). If we posit that the universe was universal ad arguendo, then an infinite succession of past events is required to reach the present. In such a case, the present will never come about, because there will be an infinitely increasing sequence of required histories before it can happen, therefore defeating the idea of infinite history.

You could argue that matter is eternal and predates the “start of time.” The problem with that is that you would have to concede that the original matter was limited, static, and incapable itself of starting history. So what caused time to begin and matter to start expanding into the visible cosmos?

Regardless, all of this is a problem only with the Kalam cosmological argument. The dependency argument does not have these problems, including the eternality issue.

However belief in Allah is not predicated on these arguments. Belief in Allah is the most intuitive default view which must then be falsified for good reasons. If we start without the belief in Allah, we have some really big fish to fry before we can propose a coherent alternative worldview (solipsism, philosophical zombies, Boltzmann brains, logicial nihilism, etc.).

Posted September 7, 2026. Read it on Reddit.

Find me on Reddit, YouTube, Letterboxd and Linktree; more of my work is on my portfolio, alishukriamin.com.

Categories
Islamic Scholarship

Why Follow a Madhhab? A Doctor’s Analogy

Adapted from a discussion on whether Muslims should simply identify as Muslims rather than follow a madhhab (school of law).

Let's ask a different question:

Would you go to a doctor who refused to tell anyone what university they studied medicine at?

You, as a person in need of a doctor, don't need to identify as a graduate of Harvard medical school or John Hopkins or any other medical school.

However, you surely want evidence that your doctor has studied medicine in a systematic fashion so you can trust his prescriptions.

Din is the same way. As a layman, you don't need to identify as following "Harvard's medical curriculum" or a particular madh'hab. But when you need a ruling, you want to make sure the person giving it is properly licensed to do so. In Islamic law, the institutions that properly license someone are the madhahib.

If you decide you want to actually study in a serious way, you don't go and take 101 level courses at 4 universities. Someone who is a freshman at 4 different schools doesn't get a degree. You pick one school and continue until you get a bachelor's, master's, or PhD.

Similarly, when you are ready to take fiqh more seriously, you pick a madh'hab and study it.

The madhahib are not personalities or sects or identifiers, and some extremists do take them as such. They are schools to systematically study law.

If you felt very ill, would you trust yourself to conduct independent online research to treat yourself? Or your parents? Or your children?

Or would you rather have a qualified doctor take a look?

That's the same thing with Islamic rulings and evidence. The layman can spend all day researching Quran & hadith online, just like you can look up pharmaceuticals & research papers. That will never replace 8 years of university plus residency to become an actual MD. Similarly, online research of Islamic sources will never replace an 8 year alim program plus independent scholarly study.


This began as a comment I wrote on Reddit. Read it in context here: https://www.reddit.com/r/islam/comments/1w9158g/why_cant_we_just_identify_as_muslims_instead_of/p87uam2/